Does Qt 5.15 support OpenSSL 3.x?

QuantumTransistor

I tried compiling the open-source Qt 5.15.10 with OpenSSL 3.1.1 in Windows 11 (VS 2022) using:

-openssl-runtime OPENSSL_INCDIR="C:\Path\Tp\OpenSSL\3.1.1\include"

in the configure call. Compiling Qt worked fine, but at run time, QSslSocket::sslLibraryBuildVersionString() returns

Qt OpenSSL build version: "OpenSSL 3.1.1 30 May 2023"
[2023-07-18 8:34:19.625][W][qt.network.ssl] `anonymous-namespace'::qsslSocketCannotResolveSymbolWarning():132 - QSslSocket: cannot resolve EVP_PKEY_base_id
[2023-07-18 8:34:19.625][W][qt.network.ssl] `anonymous-namespace'::qsslSocketCannotResolveSymbolWarning():132 - QSslSocket: cannot resolve SSL_get_peer_certificate

I'm still not sure if OpenSSL 3.x is fundamentally incompatible with Qt 5.15.x, or if other changes are needed.

(Note, I followed the same compiling and linking steps which work with Qt 5.15.x and OpenSSL 1.1.1).

Taytoo

@QuantumTransistor I link with openssl statically and also use vcpkg to manage external libraries - makes it really easy to update libraries in few simple commands.

Anyway, you need to specify path to library and header files e.g. part of my configure command:

-openssl-linked OPENSSL_LIBS="-llibssl -llibcrypto -lws2_32 -lAdvapi32 -lCrypt32 -lUser32" -I C:\Dev\vcpkg\installed\x86-windows-static\include -I C:\Dev\vcpkg\installed\x86-windows-static\include\openssl -L C:\Dev\vcpkg\installed\x86-windows-static\lib

julianoes

@SGaist said in Does Qt 5.15 support OpenSSL 3.x?:

Depending on the distribution you use, its own Qt version may already be patched to support OpenSSL v3.

That's an interesting comment. Thanks @SGaist. So far, we always downloaded Qt using the installer and used that to build. Depending on the OS (ubuntu 22.04) one tended to be tricky and the wrong version but I might give that a try.

It's a shame that Qt doesn't make a patch release to fixup something security related like that.

JKSH

@julianoes said in Does Qt 5.15 support OpenSSL 3.x?:

It's a shame that Qt doesn't make a patch release to fixup something security related like that.

Qt 5.15 has reached end-of-life (see https://www.qt.io/blog/qt-5.15-support-ends ). When security is important, use an actively-maintained version. Qt 6.5 uses OpenSSL 3 by default.

QuantumTransistor

Thanks @Taytoo, I'll give static linking a try. Which version of Qt are you using? This bug report gives a patch for using 5.15.9 with OpenSSL 3. I'm using 5.15.10 (the latest available open-source), and not sure if a similar patch is still needed.

QuantumTransistor

Following the suggestion from @Taytoo, I got Qt5.15.10 and OpenSSL 3.1.1 to work correctly for my application.

OpenSSL configure settings were:

-openssl-linked OPENSSL_INCDIR="C:\Path\To\OpenSSL\3.1.1\include" OPENSSL_LIBDIR="C:\Path\To\OpenSSL\3.1.1\lib\VC\static" OPENSSL_LIBS="-lWs2_32 -lGdi32 -lAdvapi32 -lCrypt32 -lUser32" OPENSSL_LIBS_DEBUG="-llibssl64MDd -llibcrypto64MDd" OPENSSL_LIBS_RELEASE="-llibssl64MD -llibcrypto64MD"

Still a bit puzzled why -openssl-runtime doesn't work, but I'll keep trying now that I know the codes are compatible.

Taytoo

@QuantumTransistor I've never linked with openssl dynamically, so can't really help with that. Try changing Lib path to point towards .so/.dll files instead and see if that works.

seyed

I used OpenSSL 3 to build Qt 5.15.10 successfully, but at runtime, I faced problems:

qt.network.ssl: QSslSocket: cannot resolve EVP_PKEY_base_id
qt.network.ssl: QSslSocket: cannot resolve SSL_get_peer_certificate
Build version: "OpenSSL 3.1.1 30 May 2023"
Run version: "OpenSSL 3.1.1 30 May 2023"
Supports SSL: true

Finally, porting changes from Qt 6 to 5 results in a successful build and run. 🎉
Read my gist for steps

QuantumTransistor

@seyed - I used the patch from your gist and was able to successfully build and use Qt 5.15.10 with OpenSSL 3.1.2 using -openssl-runtime. Thanks!! 🎉

ocgltd

I hope to avoid rebuilding Qt + patches. Will Qt release a 5.15.x update that will allow compilation against openssl 3 ?

SGaist

@ocgltd if memory serves well, the 5.15 LTS has support for OpenSSL 3 so it should eventually come to be.

You might want to check the KDE patch set for Qt.

QuantumTransistor

@ocgltd according to a comment on this bug report, OpenSSL 3 is supported with Qt 5.15.13 onwards. If you are using the open-source version, this should be available 9 March 2024 (one year after the commercial release date).

piervalli

@QuantumTransistor
Openssl works with 5.15.13 (open source) but we need to compiare with c++17

SGaist

@piervalli what issue do you have with C++17 ?
Qt 5 requires C++11 and OpenSSL is C.

piervalli

@SGaist
The issue is with Qt 5.15.13 and build by source I haved setted c++17 for that error.
text\qlocale_win.cpp:498:60: error: 'size' is not a member of 'std'

I used Mingw 8.1

JonB

@piervalli
Since https://en.cppreference.com/w/cpp/iterator/size states that C++17 onward is required for std::size() it ought be present. (You might show line #498 of text\qlocale_win.cpp so we know what the call looks like.) That implies either you are not setting for C++17 correctly or the MinGW does not have correct support for it. You might look in the appropriate std::... header file to see what is/is not there for this.

piervalli

@JonB Thanks

JonB

@piervalli
Hang on, I see a problem!

Go to that cppreference page. Look at the sample code. Go pick the various c++17 compilers it offers. With GCC 13.1 (C++17) it compiles fine. But with GCC 5.2 (C++17) I get the same error as you show.

So which gcc is the MinGW supposed to emulate? You can go to https://godbolt.org/ and play with selecting different compilers, they include MinGW choices. The oldest they have is MinGW gcc 11.3.0, that seems to work (only errors on std::ssize() in that code, which requires C++20, fair enough).