Layout, widgets not inside ???

SPlatten

@JoeCFD , thank you, so is this a Qt bug? as the link I posted before doesn't use QButtonGroup ?

JoeCFD

@SPlatten It is true that that is a bug in the example. You copied it from there. If qbuttongroup is not used, you have to have a slot onButtonClicked to toggle them(messy). Sometimes, you may need it for your app.

QButtonGroup is very helpful. Now you know how to use it.

SPlatten

@JoeCFD , I'll try to describe what I'm working on, I am developing an engine that reads the configuration of what will be contained in a window from an XML set of files. The XML can be edited and reloaded into the engine with no source code changes required, the engine renders the content of the XML file converting it to widgets, as an example:

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<form title="Test form" id="frmTest" hspacing="0" vspacing="0" width="480"
	  height="480" modal="false">
	<entry control="listwidget" label="Select:" id="enSEL"
		   cols="24" rows="1" mode="single" excludeFromChangeCheck="true"
		   resetPropertiesOnChange="true" eol="true">
		<subscriber signal="itemSelectionChanged" 
					target="simon2.js@listWidgetHandler"/>		
		<subscriber signal="currentItemChanged"
					target="simon2.js@listWidgetChanged"/>		
	</entry>
	<entry control="lineedit" label="First name:" id="enFN" eol="true"
		   cols="24" maxlength="24" accept="alpha_only" dbfield="vcFirstName"/>
	<entry control="lineedit" label="Surnname:" id="enSN" eol="true"
		   cols="24" maxlength="24" accept="alpha_only" dbfield="vcSurName"/>
	<groupbox id="enSEX" eol="true" align="left" layout="vertical" 
			  dbfield="vcSex" properties="QGroupBox { border-radius: 8px; background-color:#ff0000; }">
		<radiobutton id="rdoM" text="Male" default="true" position="0,0"/>
		<radiobutton id="rdoF" text="Female" position="1,0"/>
	</groupbox>
	<entry control="checkbox" label="Employed:" id="enEmp" eol="true"
		  dbfield="intEmployed"/>
	<entry control="textedit" label="Address:" id="enADR" eol="true"
		   maxlength="256" accept="alpha_numeric" cols="24" rows="5"
		   dbfield="vcAddress"/>
	<groupbox id="enButtons" eol="true" align="right" layout="horizontal">		   
		<button id="btnApply" api="applyChanges">
			<subscriber signal="clicked" target="simon2.js@applyButton"/>
		</button>
		<button id="btnUndo" api="undoChanges"/>
		<button id="btnOK" api="submitAndClose"/>	
	</groupbox>			
	<on saveChanges="Save changes before changing selection?"/>
	<on setup="simon2.js@setupForm"/>
</form>

I'm still having problems in getting the layout and groupbox to work properly, now I am getting a problem where after setting the layout, the code jumps into QWidgetRepaintManager::removeDirtyWidget.

This happens immediately after I call setLayout on the QGroupBox widget.

SGaist

Are you giving a parent to the layout before calling setLayout ?

JoeCFD

@SPlatten Good stuff. Can you please show your code for building layout? XML file has only properties of widgets and can not tell why layout goes wrong.

A good practice for debugging is to keep a small GUI case with ui file generated from qt designer and then you compile this case. From ui_*** file created in build, you can see how widgets are laid out. In this way, you can save a lot of time. I believe your time worths some good money.

SPlatten

@JoeCFD , the issue I have now is that I've created a mock up using Qt Creator and in this I added a QGroupBox, then into this I added a QVBoxLayout then added three QRadioButtons, I then examined the document as XML and everything looked fine, when I build and ran it also looked fine.

However I'm having difficulty replicating this, I have a QGroupBox, I've created a layout and used setLayout on the QGroupBox widget, so far so good....but now I want to set the parent to the layout but can't, because the layouts are not derived from QWidget and calling ->widget() on the layout returns nullptr. I want to use the layout like a widget so I can add other widgets to it using the layout as a parent.

jsulm

@SPlatten said in Layout, widgets not inside ???:

I want to use the layout like a widget so I can add other widgets to it using the layout as a parent.

You can't. A layout is not QWidget. And I'm wondering why you want to do this? There is already a simple way to add a widget to a layout.

SPlatten

@jsulm, I've tried implementing this:

            QLayout* pobjLayout(nullptr);
            if ( pobjParent != nullptr ) {
    //Does the parent have a layout?
                pobjLayout = pobjParent->pobjGetLayout();
                if ( pobjLayout != nullptr ) {
    //Yes, clear the pobjParWidget widget
                    pobjParWidget = nullptr;
                }
            }
            pobjWidget = qobject_cast<QWidget*>(clsCNT::pCreate(this,
                                                                mstrName,
                                                                strCSS,
                                                                slstProperties,
                                                                pobjParWidget));
            if ( pobjLayout != nullptr ) {
    //Add the widget to the layout
                pobjLayout->addWidget(pobjWidget);                
            }

However this doesn't work either, the radio buttons still appear outside of the groupbox and not in the layout, I've single stepped the logic, so the radio button widgets are added to the layout.

jsulm

@SPlatten said in Layout, widgets not inside ???:

pobjLayout->addWidget(pobjWidget)

Is this line executed?
If it is: to which widget does this layout belong? What is pobjGetLayout() actually doing?

SPlatten

@jsulm , yes, it is. I've used setObjectName to assign the layouts and widgets the id's they have in the XML.

In the above pobjLayout points to a QVBoxLayout and pobjWidget points to a QRadioButton.

The layout is appended to a QGroupBox via setLayout.

JoeCFD

@JoeCFD said in Layout, widgets not inside ???:

QString group_style_sheet = QString("QGroupBox{border: %1px solid gray;border-radius: %2px;margin-top: %3px;}" )
.arg( m_groupBorderThickness )
.arg( m_groupBorderRadius )
.arg( text_font_size * 1.6 );

override the style sheet of group box in the xml with
int margin_top = font().pointSize()* 1.6;
QString group_style_sheet = QString("QGroupBox{border: 2px solid gray;border-radius: 8px;margin-top: %1px;}" ).arg( margin_top );
You try to hardcode it and see if it works.

SPlatten

@JoeCFD , thank you appreciated, why isn't this kind of thing required when positioning and using Qt Creator? This is the XML copied from the UI file which works perfectly.

   <widget class="QGroupBox" name="groupBox">
    <property name="geometry">
     <rect>
      <x>120</x>
      <y>170</y>
      <width>301</width>
      <height>201</height>
     </rect>
    </property>
    <property name="title">
     <string>GroupBox</string>
    </property>
    <widget class="QWidget" name="verticalLayoutWidget">
     <property name="geometry">
      <rect>
       <x>9</x>
       <y>29</y>
       <width>291</width>
       <height>161</height>
      </rect>
     </property>
     <layout class="QVBoxLayout" name="verticalLayout">
      <item>
       <widget class="QRadioButton" name="Radio1">
        <property name="text">
         <string>Radio1</string>
        </property>
       </widget>
      </item>
      <item>
       <widget class="QRadioButton" name="Radio2">
        <property name="text">
         <string>Radio2</string>
        </property>
       </widget>
      </item>
      <item>
       <widget class="QRadioButton" name="Radio3">
        <property name="text">
         <string>Radio3</string>
        </property>
       </widget>
      </item>
     </layout>
    </widget>
   </widget>
  </widget>
 </widget>

No sign of any styles or positioning, I'm now trying to reverse the logic to see where the difference is.

This is what I found in the debugger looking at how the above XML appears:
Screenshot 2021-10-20 at 18.06.21.png
What I don't understand is what is **[0] "verticalLayout" as a child ?

Drill down a bit more into this layout:
Screenshot 2021-10-20 at 18.25.22.png
It appears that the groupBox has one child which I agree with and expect verticalLayoutWidget, the layout has 4 children which I didn't expect:

verticalLayout
Radio1
Radio2
Radio3

What is verticalLayout and where did it come from, it has no children, it isn't in the XML layout ?

Just to clarify, just in case the screenshot isn't clear it shows:

groupBox
    verticalLayout
        verticalLayoutWidget
        Radio1
        Radio2
        Radio3

Its verticalLayoutWidget that is the mystery...

Another edit, looked again at the XML and it does match the debugger screenshot. It looks like there is a fiddle in that the first widget is not the QVBoxLayout but a Widget called "verticalLayoutWidget".

JoeCFD

@SPlatten group box has a layout for three radio buttons and is a child as well. In total, it has 4 children.

SPlatten

@JoeCFD, please see edit, bit at the bottom.

JoeCFD

@SPlatten You created a verticalLayoutWidget inside a group box which has 4 children:
verticalLayout
radio1
radio2
radio3

verticalLayoutWidget is not needed. the parent of verticalLayoutWidget is groupBox.

SPlatten

@JoeCFD , to repeat what I did:

Dragged Group Box from Containers palette and dropped onto centralWidget
Dragged Vertical Layout from Layouts palette and dropped onto Group Box
Dragged Radio Button from Buttons palette and dropped onto Vertical Layout
Dragged Radio Button from Buttons palette and dropped onto Vertical Layout
Dragged Radio Button from Buttons palette and dropped onto Vertical Layout
Edited text attribute for each control

Thats it, one layout not two. Take a look at the XML I posted, its pretty clear and its the actual elements that are generated from this XML that I'm questioning.

JoeCFD

@JoeCFD
if there is no title for the group, set top margin to 0
QString group_style_sheet = QString("QGroupBox{border: 2px solid gray;border-radius: 8px;margin-top: 0px;}" );

SPlatten

@JoeCFD , but why? What I'm trying to understand is why if done in Qt Creator WYSIWYG, no fiddles are required and it works, but the code generated from the XML just doesn't add up.

JoeCFD

@SPlatten Could be some global settings in your project which cause this problem. Since all my widgets are customized, I do not complain about this. BTW, border-radius setting is bad sometimes when screen resolution is not high enough. Often, I have to set it to 0.

SPlatten

@JoeCFD , please see latest edit....

Update: Forum Guidelines & Code of Conduct

Qt World Summit: Early-Bird Tickets

Unsolved Layout, widgets not inside ???