Build on Linux: -qt-xcb option?

Bob64

Hi

Thanks for the hints. I took a closer look at the config.log. Earlier I had mainly looked at config.summary but I didn't really know what I was looking for. Anyway in the log, the only thing that fails that explicitly mentions xcb is the following:

looking for library xcb_icccm
Trying source 0 (type pkgConfig) of library xcb_icccm ...
+ /usr/bin/pkg-config --exists --silence-errors xcb-icccm '>=' 0.3.9
pkg-config did not find package.
  => source produced no result.
Trying source 1 (type inline) of library xcb_icccm ...
xcb/xcb_icccm.h not found in [] and global paths.
  => source produced no result.
test config.qtbase_gui.libraries.xcb_icccm FAILED

As I mentioned I wasn't sure I had all packages installed. Will the packages listed in the Qt docs for Debian have the same name in CentOS 7.4? Do I need to worry about what versions to install etc.? (Sorry I am a noob at this!)

Going back to my original question, why doesn't configure recognise the -qt-xcb option for me - do I need to worry about that?

Bob64

I have gone through the dependencies listed in the Qt doc and looked for equivalents on my system or available for installation. Most appear to be there if I ignore slight naming differences (no numbers in the CentOS package names). libxi-dev and libxkbcommon-x11-dev equivalents aren't installed but are available. However, I can't see libx11-xcb-dev or libxcb-glx0-dev.

libfontconfig1-dev    fontconfig-devel.x86_64
libfreetype6-dev      freetype-devel.x86_64
libx11-dev            libX11-devel.x86_64
libxext-dev           libXext-devel.x86_64
libxfixes-dev         libXfixes-devel.x86_64
libxi-dev             Not installed: libXi-devel.x86_64
libxrender-dev        libXrender-devel.x86_64 
libxcb1-dev           libxcb-devel.x86_64
libx11-xcb-dev        ?
libxcb-glx0-dev       ?
libxkbcommon-x11-dev  Not installed: libxkbcommon-x11-devel.x86_64

Note that this list is the one specified for when configuring with -qt-xcb which as I have mentioned does not work for me - gives error:

ERROR: Invalid value given for boolean command line option 'xcb'.

There are a bunch of other dependencies listed in the Qt doc for if one doesn't compile with this option. These are all of the form libxcb-<something>-dev. I can find plausible looking CentOS equivalents for <something> = keysmys1, image0, render-util0 but none of the others (including libxcb-icccm4-dev, which stands out because of the configure error relating to xcb-icccm that I mentioned earlier).

SGaist

From a quick search, try with "libxcbutil-icccm".

Bob64

@SGaist Thanks. It wasn't showing up as a package available for download on my machine's package manager. I did do a quick web search and I found one match but for a different CentOS version and I don't know if it was an "official" source.

In any case, I think that package should only be needed for the non -qt-xcb case. I would still like to understand what is going on there. Is that option no longer available in configure? Is the documentation now incorrect? Has it been replaced with a different setting?

Christian Ehrlicher

-qt-xcb was removed from configure (and also from the documentation for 5.15 but the official site did not pick up the lastest version yet - see https://codereview.qt-project.org/c/qt/qtdoc/+/300877/3/doc/src/platforms/linux.qdoc )

SGaist

@Christian-Ehrlicher said in Build on Linux: -qt-xcb option?:

-qt-xcb was removed from configure (and also from the documentation for 5.15 but the official site did not pick up the lastest version yet - see https://codereview.qt-project.org/c/qt/qtdoc/+/300877/3/doc/src/platforms/linux.qdoc )

Good catch, I forgot about that one.

Joshua Fletcher

I'm seeing a similar problem on centOS 7.2, but I've previously installed earlier versions of Qt without a problem.
For me, Qt 5.15.0 seems to be installing, but the X11Extras is not, and I need the X11Extras module to install successfully.

looking at the logs of a successful and working Qt 5.12 installation, it mentioned iccm failures there, too, but that seemed to be inconsequential, since those installations worked for me.

What stands out in my case is a complete absence of any reference to render or xrender in the logs for the 5.15.0 installation.

When I tried "-bundled-xcb-xinput", my config.summary said this:
"WARNING: Feature system-xcv-xinput is insignificant in this configuration, ignoring related command line option(s)."

It didn't seem to make any difference.

As an experiment, the original poster could try installing Qt 5.14.0, to compare. I was able to install that on CentOS 7.2.
If that is successful, we might have the same problem, and comparing a successful 5.14 installation with a problematic 5.15 installation might help. We may both need the same solution.

Christian Ehrlicher

@Joshua-Fletcher said in Build on Linux: -qt-xcb option?:

We may both need the same solution.

The solution is to use xcb from the distribution since it no longer is shipped with Qt.

Bob64

@Christian-Ehrlicher Thank you! That is a big help as it eliminates one of the main things that was confusing me.

The problem is now reduced to resolving the list of dependencies. I can't believe that if icccm (for example) is so important that it is not available more easily so I am wondering if it gets bundled with another package on CentOS. I am going to have to ask for packages to be installed as I don't have privileges at the moment, which is why it would be useful to have a definitive list of what is needed on CentOS.

Joshua Fletcher

I found that ensuring these packages were installed was sufficient for my purposes:
libxcb-devel
libxkbcommon-devel
xcb-util-devel
xcb-util-image-devel
xcb-util-keysyms-devel
xcb-util-renderutil-devel
xcb-util-wm-devel
mesa-libGL-devel

the only one I was actually missing was: xcb-util-renderutil-devel
but if you can, check and make sure all those are installed, and I think it should work for you.

ludek.vodicka

Hi, I just also trying to solve problems with -qt-xcb option.

I removed this switch and compiled the latest Qt 5.15.0. But my application didn't start with error:

qt.qpa.plugin: Could not find the Qt platform plugin "xcb" in ""
This application failed to start because no Qt platform plugin could be initialized. Reinstalling the application may fix this problem.
Available platform plugins are: linuxfb, minimal, offscreen, vnc.

Directory qt\plugis\platforms contains only

libqlinuxfb.so
libqminimal.so
libqoffscreen.so
libqvnc.so

Thanks for any help

JoeCFD

https://forum.qt.io/topic/93247/qt-qpa-plugin-could-not-load-the-qt-platform-plugin-xcb-in-even-though-it-was-found

ludek.vodicka

@JoeCFD Thanks for the reply. I already saw this topic but it is a slightly different problem.

I do not have a message:

Qt platform plugin "xcb" in "" even though it was found.
but only
Qt platform plugin "xcb" in ""

My issue is that I don't have file libqxcb.so in Qt/plugins/platform directory at all.

I tried to compile it with -qt-xcb like several times before, but because this switch was removed, I tried it without that. Also, I tried "-xcb" switch too.

But although I have "X11 specific: XCB Xlib...yes" message during configuration, libqxcb.so file isn't created.

ludek.vodicka

Seems that adding following switches forces Qt to build libxcb.so

-xcb -xcb-xlib -bundled-xcb-input

(it's necessary to add all these switches based on my observations)

Jawsh

@ludek-vodicka, where do you specify those options? They are not part of configure, correct?

jsulm

@Jawsh said in Build on Linux: -qt-xcb option?:

They are not part of configure

They are. Call configure with -h parameter and you will see.

Jawsh

Actually, if I remove bundled-xcb-input it works on configure. However, I have run into a new error: "ERROR: Feature 'xcb' was enabled, but the pre-condition 'features.thread && libs.xcb && tests.xcb_syslibs && features.xkbcommon-x11' failed." Anyone have any ideas? I have installed as many of the prerequisite libs as I could find listed.

Jawsh

Found this on: https://github.com/RudolfCardinal/camcops/issues/3

sudo apt-get build-dep qt5-default

(having enabled "Source code" option in Software and Updates > Ubuntu Software)

After I did this, deleted config.cache, and reran configure then it worked.

SeanMurphy_6

I had this exact same problem and I found that if I combined the installing the packages listed by Joshua Fletcher on 16 Jun 2020:

libxcb-devel
libxkbcommon-devel
xcb-util-devel
xcb-util-image-devel
xcb-util-keysyms-devel
xcb-util-renderutil-devel
xcb-util-wm-devel
mesa-libGL-devel

And then running configure with the options suggested by Ludek Vodicka on 19 Jun 2020:

-xcb
-xcb-xlib
-bundled-xcb-xinput

Built Qt and correctly built the libqxcb.so under the platforms plugin directory, and now my applications compiled against Qt 5.15.2 launch without any errors.

nikhil-sethi

Hey everyone. I was facing the same issue on Ubuntu 20.04. This thread and @SeanMurphy_6's solution (23rd Nov) helped me a lot. Thanks for that.
Just wanted to add that it is important to use the 'dev' versions of the xcb libraries. In my case I had the latest 'xcb xinerama0' library installed but libqxcb.so still didn't compile. Fixed it by installing the dev version (libxcb-xinerama0-dev on Debian/Ubuntu). If all xcb libraries are installed correctly, you should

See a 'yes' for each xcb library on the CLI when running the configure command:

Checking XCB XINERAMA .... yes

See a 'succeeded' for tests in the config.log file:

test config.qtbase_gui.libraries.xcb_xinerama succeeded

When compiled you should see libqxcb.so in the qtbase/plugins/platforms directory
The original software ran perfectly after ensuring this.