Diagnosing audio problems

nulluse

I realize that Unix Qt multimedia is Gstreamer based.
Is not having any audio devices in Qt indicative of a problem with Gstreamer install?

nulluse

If sound works in KDE but not in my Qt app, what does that mean?

SGaist

Hi,

Not necessarily but you should check your GStreamer install.

nulluse

Gstreamer appears to work just fine with Audacity, Ardour, VLC and all possible KDE and GTK players etc. I cannot find any fault with Gstreamer, even installed "all" plugins package and still no devices detected by Qt.

SGaist

Which version of Qt did you install ? How did you install it ?

nulluse

It was Qt5 from the FreeBSD packages (not from the ports): pkg install Qt5
It seems to be version 5.5.1

When compiled and run under Windows 7 this prints:

Device name:  "Speakers (Realtek High Definiti" 
Device name:  "Acer P241W (2- High Definition "  // a monitor, actually. HDMI connection, that's probably why?
Device name:  "Realtek Digital Output (Realtek"

So this probably has something to do with Qt configuration on the FreeBSD machine, it probably does not know something critical about Gstreamer.

SGaist

Did you check that you have all QtMultimedia plugins installed ?

nulluse

Oh, on Unix that would be

PulseAudio (Unix)
Alsa (Unix)

That may be the case: FreeBSD comes with OSS and Alsa is optional. I did not have Alsa installed, that may be it. I will install, re-test and reply back.

But I do not understand why Gstreamer is not sufficient if it is Qt's back end for Unix.
And how could KDE sound work if Qt could not detect any audio devices. This simply does not make any sense.

SGaist

Depending on your version of KDE, it's phonon that's used.

nulluse

So what's the next step?

SGaist

Start your application with QT_DEBUG_PLUGINS=1 to see what's going on when your application starts.

nulluse

These lines have something to do with audio:

QFactoryLoader::QFactoryLoader() checking directory path "/usr/local/lib/qt5/plugins/audio" ... // there is no audio directory
QFactoryLoader::QFactoryLoader() checking directory path "/usr/home/leo/NetBeansProjects/OscilloscopeQT/dist/Debug/GNU-Generic/audio" ...
QFactoryLoader::QFactoryLoader() checking directory path "/usr/home/leo/.kde4/lib/kde4/plugins/audio" ... // there is no .kde4/lib
QFactoryLoader::QFactoryLoader() checking directory path "/usr/local/lib/kde4/plugins/audio" ... // also no audio directory

Is there a manual on installing the Qt audio plugins under Unix?

SGaist

That looks strange, you should check with the FreeBSD guys.

nulluse

According to https://bugs.freebsd.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=208987 multimedia audio plugins cannot be installed from the packages under FreeBSD.
They have to be compiled from the ports tree and select the options to build audio plugins and use ALSA or PA:

cd /usr/ports/multimedia/qt5-multimedia
make config 
make deinstall install clean

But still there are no devices recognized after reinstalling with the compiled audio plugins:

 QFactoryLoader::QFactoryLoader() checking directory path "/usr/local/lib/qt5/plugins/audio" ...
 QFactoryLoader::QFactoryLoader() looking at "/usr/local/lib/qt5/plugins/audio/libqtaudio_alsa.so"
Found metadata in lib /usr/local/lib/qt5/plugins/audio/libqtaudio_alsa.so, metadata=
 {
"IID": "org.qt-project.qt.audiosystemfactory/5.0",
"MetaData": {
 "Keys": [
"alsa"
]
 },
 "className": "QAlsaPlugin",
 "debug": false,
"version": 328961
 }


Got keys from plugin meta data ("alsa")
QFactoryLoader::QFactoryLoader() checking directory path "/usr/local/lib/kde4/plugins/audio" ...
 loaded library "/usr/local/lib/qt5/plugins/audio/libqtaudio_alsa.so"
 Device count: 0
Device count: 0

SGaist

What about PA ?

nulluse

I am very hesitant to use or rely on PA due to horrible latency and frankly the whole concept of having a sound server where only mic input and speaker output are required sounds outlandish to me.