Native TextEdit Context Menu on OS X

[bmeric]

Hi,

Qt Quick Controls 1(Qt 5.8) uses wrong context menu with textedit on OS X(OS X Sierra). Is there a way to trigger OS X native context menu? Is this issue affect App Store approval process?

[jsulm]

@bmeric Why do you think it is wrong?
What a context menu contains depends on the application.

[bmeric]

Hi @jsulm,
1- Spelling corrections, Speech, etc default with every native textedit context menu in OS X, users expect that. So, from UX point of view, it's wrong.
2- Shortcuts shouldn't be visible in a context menu in OS X("Don’t display keyboard shortcuts in a contextual menu. A contextual menu is a shortcut to a set of task-specific commands, so it's redundant to display the keyboard shortcuts for those commands. " - Apple's Human Interface Guidelines docs.)