Important: Please read the Qt Code of Conduct - https://forum.qt.io/topic/113070/qt-code-of-conduct
C++11 Threads in Android Toolchain
I'm trying to use an existing library developed in C++11, it uses std threads. I can't create a C++11 thread in a android app, when the thread constructor runs I get a seg fault error.
My Tool Chain in Windows 7 is:
Qt Creator 3.1.0
Android SDK for API 18 (Jelly)
Android NDK r9d
Deploying on Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 2014 edition
It compiles, and even can get the correct result for std::thread::hardware_concurrency().
I tryed to set the flag: APP_CPPFLAGS = -std=c++11 and still same problem.
Vincent007 last edited by
Did you test your code on other platforms?
s.frings74 last edited by
Multi-Threading depends on support by the Linux Kernel. Your application communicates to the kernel using the C libraries that are shipped as part of the Android operating system.
Let me guess: The std libraries installed on the Android system are not compiled with C++11, so they don't support threads.
It's possibly similiar to Java: A program that has ben compiled with Java 6 or 7 can run on Java 5 as long it does not use any of the new features.
Vincent: Yes the code is fine in other platforms.
s.frings: Yes multi-threading depends on support on the kernel, but it does not mean they need to be compiled with C++11, it is not how it works. Android underlying kernel with no doubt has thread support.
I believe the problem may lie on android NDK, some config flag that I'm not aware of. Thats what I'm asking :) My NDK toolchain is configured for GCC 4.8 and android-18.
To test it out, one can simply create a foo method inside a class (could be the main form) and call the thread constructor like:
std::thread newThread(&MyClass::FooMethod, this);
it will crash inside the constructor, in my current configuration.
Vincent007 last edited by
I saw someone encountered the same issue. Perhaps, it is a bug.
You can try to use QThread instread of std thread.
Unfortunately I can't use Qt Threads in this module :/ At least not right now.
It is maintained as a pure C++11 module, for reuse in other IDEs/Toolchains.
I'm still testing, if anyone knows why it does not work.
I found out that people are able to use std threads when using Android NDK, like "this":http://binglongx.wordpress.com/2013/04/07/c11-on-android/ or "this":http://stackoverflow.com/questions/20021527/android-ndk-r9b-and-compiling-c11
But inside Qt Creator it is not working :/
@std::thread t2(&MainWindow::ThreadAction, this, "Thread 2");@
Using a class member function with one std::string parameter to create a thread, I reproduced the error and got two images, one with disassembler and other that shows std tuple line of code that occurs the segmentation fault.
I found out the problem ¬¬
Due to an if clause misplaced the detach() was never called...
Always remeber to check for a call to join() or detach() ;)