Important: Please read the Qt Code of Conduct - https://forum.qt.io/topic/113070/qt-code-of-conduct

Optimization in debug mode using or not debugging



  • Hi,

    recently I have imported in my project a particular algorithm that was already written on an old project. After a lot of testing where I only used the debugger I tried to run the program without it. What I noticed is that it's behaviour is different: when I use the debugger everything works perfectly but when I simply run the program the output is different. It looks like there is a sort of optimization if I run without the debugger.
    For both I'am workoing on debug mode, I am not talking about debug and release mode.

    Is it something somebody has already run into? Do you have any advice?

    I'm working on windows 10 using Qt 5.9.1 MinGW 32 bit.


  • Lifetime Qt Champion

    @davidesalvetti said in Optimization in debug mode using or not debugging:

    output is different

    In what way? It is hard to guess without more information.



  • @jsulm sorry for not mention that.

    I have a QVector array that is filled inside the algorithm. If I launch the app with the debugger I get some values that I know are correct. But when I run it without the debugger I get a lot of values more. Let's say with debugger I get 3 values that are correct and without it I get 12 values that are not correct.
    So I thought that there must be a difference when I run a program with debugger and when I run it without it.
    Unfortunately I cannot put the algorithm here for a matter of copyright, I know that this is not so much...

    Is there some optimization when debugging or some other option that is different and that i can check? Honestly it's not the first time that variables behave different when in debugging.



  • Any suggestion?


  • Lifetime Qt Champion

    @davidesalvetti No, without source code I can't tell.
    Usually such issues are caused by not initialised variables (behaviour is different between debug and release builds). So, check your code for such issues.


  • Lifetime Qt Champion

    Hi
    Since you mention its always a debug build, then the normal suspects between release/debug does not apply.
    However, debugging can alter the normal timings of the app so it can be related to anything you do asynchronous like with a timer or thread.



  • You mention that " with debugger I get 3 values that are correct and without it I get 12 values that are not correct." Does this mean that the algorithm always outputs a certain fraction of values that are correct and the rest is wrong? If yes, where does the randomness come from? Is there some random-call in there or indirectly from a race condition or something?



  • @gde23 thanks for your answer.

    I don't have threads or QTimer so I would exclude race conditions. The algorithm is executed in the main thread and is executed from the beginning till the end, that's why it's really strange and I can't understand this difference between using the debugger or not.


Log in to reply