QTableView sort indicator not shows

jronald

MainWindow::MainWindow(QWidget *parent)
    : QMainWindow(parent)
    , ui(new Ui::MainWindow)
{
    ui->setupUi(this);

    ui->tableView_evaluator->setModel(&tableModel_evaluator);

    bool b = ui->tableView_evaluator->isSortingEnabled();
    Q_ASSERT(b);

    ui->tableView_evaluator->sortByColumn(3, Qt::AscendingOrder);

////  another method, not work
//    QHeaderView * hh = ui->tableView_evaluator->horizontalHeader();
//    hh->setSortIndicator(3, Qt::AscendingOrder);
//    hh->setSortIndicatorShown(true);
}

Everything is normal except that the sort indicator does not show.
What is the problem?

screenshot

BTW, no grid line below horizontal headers, also none for vertical headers, why?

Env:

Qt 5.13.1 AMD64
OS: Manjaro xfce AMD64

JonB

@jronald said in QTableView sort indicator not shows:
You will definitely need the version which calls setSortIndicatorShown(true), since https://doc.qt.io/qt-5/qheaderview.html#showSortIndicator-prop states that the default is false.

So you need your commented-out code. It should work. If you say it does not, try moving the sortByColumn() to after the setSortIndicator...() lines, though I don't think that will make any difference.

You might also try calling hh->setSectionsClickable(true) to see whether clicking makes the indicator visible for you, though again I don't think you should have to do that.

jronald

@JonB

Still no shown

MainWindow::MainWindow(QWidget *parent)
    : QMainWindow(parent), ui(new Ui::MainWindow)
{
    ui->setupUi(this);

    QHeaderView * hh = ui->tableView_evaluator->horizontalHeader();

    hh->setSortIndicatorShown(true);

    ui->tableView_evaluator->setModel(&tableModel_evaluator);

    hh->setSortIndicatorShown(true);

    bool b = ui->tableView_evaluator->isSortingEnabled();
    Q_ASSERT(b);

    ui->tableView_evaluator->sortByColumn(3, Qt::AscendingOrder);

    hh->setSortIndicatorShown(true);
}

JonB

@jronald
I'd also put in a

hh->setSortIndicator(3, Qt::AscendingOrder);

before the last setSortIndicatorShown(). (You can remove the earlier calls to setSortIndicatorShown().)

Humour me: I see your Q_ASSERT() (you aren't compiling for no-debug, are you?), but try putting in an explicit ui->tableView_evaluator->setSortingEnabled(true).

jronald

@JonB said in QTableView sort indicator not shows:

@jronald
I'd also put in a
hh->setSortIndicator(3, Qt::AscendingOrder);
before the last setSortIndicatorShown().

Still not work

MainWindow::MainWindow(QWidget *parent)
    : QMainWindow(parent), ui(new Ui::MainWindow)
{
    ui->setupUi(this);

    QHeaderView * hh = ui->tableView_evaluator->horizontalHeader();

    hh->setSortIndicatorShown(true);

    ui->tableView_evaluator->setModel(&tableModel_evaluator);

    hh->setSortIndicatorShown(true);

    ui->tableView_evaluator->setSortingEnabled(true);
    bool b = ui->tableView_evaluator->isSortingEnabled();
    Q_ASSERT(b);

//    ui->tableView_evaluator->sortByColumn(3, Qt::AscendingOrder);

    hh->setSortIndicator(3, Qt::AscendingOrder);

    hh->setSortIndicatorShown(true);
}

Humour me: I see your Q_ASSERT() (you aren't compiling for no-debug, are you?), but try putting in an explicit ui->tableView_evaluator->setSortingEnabled(true).

Compiling in debug mode, I've set it to true in UI designer.

JonB

@jronald
Don't know then. https://stackoverflow.com/questions/43535789/how-to-set-sort-indicator-for-qtableview-programatically reports the same as you, but was never answered if the indicators truly do not show for that user. It shows the principle of what you're supposed to write. There seem to be plenty of others for whom indicators are working fine. You're not using any special "skin"/"theme" on your platform (which is what?)? Or some table style or something which might not show the indicators?

P.S.
Last thing: try a setSectionsClickable(true), just in case that influences...?

jronald

@JonB said in QTableView sort indicator not shows:

@jronald
Don't know then. https://stackoverflow.com/questions/43535789/how-to-set-sort-indicator-for-qtableview-programatically reports the same as you, but was never answered if the indicators truly do not show for that user. It shows the principle of what you're supposed to write. There seem to be plenty of others for whom indicators are working fine. You're not using any special "skin"/"theme" on your platform (which is what?)? Or some table style or something which might not show the indicators?

No, a demo simply for testing.

P.S.
Last thing: try a setSectionsClickable(true), just in case that influences...?

Tried, failed.

JonB

@jronald
OK. At this point: I can't help because I'm not C++, but:

Can you produce a 20-liner minimal (2 data rows) complete which compiles? So someone can just paste and try.
Tell us what version of Qt and what platform.
Request someone kind who fancies compiling. @mrjj is known to be very helpful at trying other people's UI stuff. :) :)
Compare their result to yours.
If it truly turns out to be inexplicable, make post on Qt bug forum.

jronald

@JonB said in QTableView sort indicator not shows:

Can you produce a 20-liner minimal (2 data rows) complete which compiles? So someone can just paste and try.

![0_1572462658913_TestQt.tar.bz2.png](Uploading 100%)
PS: rename to TestQt.tar.bz2
PS: cheating failed, the project can't be downloaded

Tell us what version of Qt and what platform.

Qt 5.13.1 AMD64
OS: Manjaro xfce AMD64

Request someone kind who fancies compiling. @mrjj is known to be very helpful at trying other people's UI stuff. :) :)

Compare their result to yours.

I'll try it on Winows later.

Christian Ehrlicher

No need to upload something (it doesn't work) - 10 lines of code are enough:

#include <QtWidgets>
int main(int argc, char **argv)
{
    QApplication app(argc, argv);
    
    QStringListModel model({"A", "B", "C", "D", "E", "F"});
    QTableView tv;
    tv.setModel(&model);
    tv.setSortingEnabled(true);
    tv.horizontalHeader()->setSortIndicatorShown(true);
    tv.show();
    return app.exec();
}

This is working fine for me.

jronald

@Christian-Ehrlicher
Thank you
It doesn't work for me.

Christian Ehrlicher

What style is this? Did you compile Qt by yourself? Please try with fusion style ("-style fusion")

mrjj

Hi
Just as a note.
works on Win 10.
alt text
Linux Mint

so it seems related to Arch linux.

jronald

@Christian-Ehrlicher said in QTableView sort indicator not shows:

What style is this?

default style of Manjaro xfce

Did you compile Qt by yourself?

No, installed by pacman

Please try with fusion style ("-style fusion")

Do you mean compile Qt with -style fusion?

Christian Ehrlicher

@jronald said in QTableView sort indicator not shows:

Compile Qt with -style fusion?

No, start the app with this parameter.

jronald

@Christian-Ehrlicher said in QTableView sort indicator not shows:

@jronald said in QTableView sort indicator not shows:

Compile Qt with -style fusion?

No, start the app with this parameter.

Nice, any way to built in the style?
BTW, "Qt5 Settings (Qt5 Configuration Tool)" can change the style used by the demo.

Thanks

VRonin

In your main() put QApplication::setStyle(QStyleFactory::create("Fusion"));