QGroupBox not fit internal layout

SGaist

Hi,

Which version of Qt ?
On which version of Windows ?
Can you please provide a minimal compilable example to reproduce this ?
The snippet you provided does not include the dialog creation nor the buttons so this might hide something else regarding your issue.

SergeyK12

This worked if size of QLabel is smaller.
But i still can minimize window less than fixed size. Because of QGroupBox. And window same as on image above.

SergeyK12

@SGaist
Latest Qt (6.7.3)
Windows

I prepare separate example (from code i mention in the post) and it is fully correct.
The difference is that i use designer with my original question.

I'm at a loss. Maybe sizes or policies...

Thanks for your help.

SergeyK12

Or maby because of QDialog i use

Axel Spoerl

The dialog is too small to fit two fixed size labels (plus a group box overhead for each). That’s why the group boxes are both cropped. Increase the dialog size and the issue goes away :-)

SergeyK12

@SergeyK12
QDialog could adjust size to it content:

But if i push this QLabel into a layout into QGroupBox

Its not ajust QGroubBox layout.

But if i do the same withoun QDialog (test example with QMainWindow)

everything is fine

SergeyK12

If i call adjustSize

SergeyK12

QGroupBox is broken with QDialog.
I could (possably) avoid this by creating CustomWidget included QGroupBox.
But the problem exist.

Christian Ehrlicher

As soon as the requested minimum size does not fit into the layout (as it seems in your example) the layout manager can't do anything.
This is working fine:

int main(int argc, char **argv)
{
    QApplication a(argc, argv);
    QWidget w;
    auto vlay = new QVBoxLayout(&w);
    for (int i = 0; i != 2; ++i) {
        auto groupBox = new QGroupBox("GroupBox");
        groupBox->setCheckable(true);
        groupBox->setAlignment(Qt::AlignLeft);

        auto* lay = new QVBoxLayout;
        auto* lab = new QLabel("Test");

        lab->setFixedSize(500, 200);
        lay->addWidget(lab);

        groupBox->setLayout(lay);
        groupBox->adjustSize();

        vlay->addWidget(groupBox);
    }
    w.show();
    return app.exec();
}

SergeyK12

@Christian-Ehrlicher
As you mention, Its perfectly work without QDialog.
In my previous post third example (it work with any number of boxes)
Thats mean that requested minimum size inside QGroupBox fit without QDialog.

Why it doesn't with QDialog?

It also work with QDialog without Boxes (first imфge in previous post).

Christian Ehrlicher

@SergeyK12 said in QGroupBox not fit internal layout:

Why it doesn't with QDialog?

Because, as I wrote above, you did not set a minimum size on your QDialog but your QWidget or whatever so the layout constraints inside are greater than your minimum size.

SergeyK12

@Christian-Ehrlicher
Sorry, i missunderstand.

I set sizes only for internal widgets.

Im not set minimum size in other working examples. So you didnt in yours.
(it calc size for any number of wigets without QGroupBox).

With QGroupBox there is additional layouts and thats the case.

I should set minimum size for QDialog?

Its some specific behaviour of QGroupBox or QDialog? (since its work with QMainWindow etc)

SergeyK12

QGroupBox and its layout live their own lives. But in all working examples they fit each other.

SergeyK12

If size of internal widget not fixed by enything its ok, but seems like nothing.
Try to combine with scroll (it will be good enough if internal widget in QScrollWidget could be any size it should be).
But fixing internal leed to this post discussion.

But its perfect (as it should be) without GroupBox (i cant understand this)

Axel Spoerl

A QGroupBox has some specific features, and so has a QDialog. They don't work together in your case, but hat doesn't constitute a bug.
The documentation of QDialog says directly at the beginning:

A dialog window is a top-level window mostly used for short-term tasks and brief communications with the user.

It seems the use case is neither short term, nor brief. If it's all about plugins, there's also no need for the power of QDialog. You could just add two push buttons to a simple QWidget at the bottom of a layout.

Without having researched it in Detail: A group box automatically has a Preferred size policy and it's a control type of its own.
E.g. the fusion style adds some space below the group box, which is accounted for in QGroupBox::minimumSizeHint(). That could be a reason.

@SergeyK12 said in QGroupBox not fit internal layout:

Try to combine with scroll (it will be good enough if internal widget in QScrollWidget could be any size it should be).

There is no such thing as a QScrollWidget. Do you mean a QScrollArea? If you do, have you tried it in combination with group boxes in a dialog?

SimonSchroeder

@Axel-Spoerl said in QGroupBox not fit internal layout:

Increase the dialog size and the issue goes away :-)

Isn't this what the outer layout is for?

@SergeyK12 In the short snippet you have showed vlay is not set as the layout of your dialog before you call this->adjustSize(). However, there is always a slight problem with this: Anything to do with the layout calculations only works after the dialog is shown. So, adjustSize() might work if you call this->show() directly before.

In general, you should rarely have a need to use fixed sizes. Everything should be handled by layouts. There might be a problem (I'm not entirely sure) that the fixed size does not communicate its behavior to the layout. The minimum size and size hint might tell the layout something entirely different. I personally would use setMinimumSize() instead of setFixedSize(). If you want to avoid for the label to be larger than the minimum size, you should set the size policy (both horizontal and vertical size policy) to QSizePolicy::Fixed. If the user still tries to make the dialog larger, something needs to be resized. You can add a QSpacerItem with zero height/width some place in your layouts to account for that (for box layouts you can use addStretch(0) directly).