Compilation of Qt5.3.1 on Ubuntu 20.04.1

SGaist

Hi and welcome to devnet,

Turn on the verbose flag, you should get some more information about what is happening.

laurent.c

Hi,

Yes, that's what I've done.

From the non-working qmake:

$ /home/lco/BSP/buildroot-output/dev/A/build/qt5base-5.3.1/bin/qmake -d -E -nocache -recursive -spec /home/lco/BSP/buildroot-output/dev/A/build/qt5base-5.3.1/mkspecs/devices/linux-buildroot-g++ QT= /dev/null
DEBUG 1: Resetting dir to: /home/lco
DEBUG 1: Changing dir to: /dev
Cannot find feature spec_pre.prf
Error processing project file: /dev/null

From the working qmake obtained from Ubuntu 14.04 and run on Ubuntu 20.01.4:

$ /home/lco/tmp/qmake -d -E -nocache -recursive -spec /home/lco/BSP/buildroot-output/dev/A/build/qt5base-5.3.1/mkspecs/devices/linux-buildroot-g++ QT= /
dev/null
DEBUG 1: Resetting dir to: /home/lco
DEBUG 1: Changing dir to: /dev
DEBUG 1: visiting file /home/lco/BSP/buildroot-output/dev/A/build/qt5base-5.3.1/mkspecs/features/spec_pre.prf

And it carries on...

SGaist

Are you building from a clean source or reusing something that already contained build artifacts ?

Are you doing out of source builds ?

laurent.c

Hi,

Yes, this is from clean Qt sources, through buildroot. So buildroot extracts the tarball of the sources, patches them and build them. I've restarted the build from scratch many times by deleting all build artifacts.

SGaist

Can you explain the procedure you are using with buildroot ?

laurent.c

This is standard buildroot build. I'm based on buildroot-2015.05. Qt5.3.1 is one of the packages to be built through the buildroot-2015.05/package/qt and buildroot-2015.05/package/qt5.
I'm cross-compiling Qt for ARM.

laurent.c

After quite a bit of debugging by adding debug messages in qmake source code, I found that the problem is related to this foreach in qmake/library/qmakeevaluator.cpp, l.1506

QStringList ret;
foreach (const QString &root, feature_roots)
    if (IoUtils::exists(root))
        ret << root;
m_featureRoots = new QMakeFeatureRoots(ret);

For some reason, this foreach does not iterate through the whole list (made of 2 elements, only the first gets iterated).
Replacing this foreach by a standard for loop makes it work.

Out of curiosity, I've looked at the latest source code, and this line was changed for a for loop at commit e31541fa6f5f4 with comment "qmake: eradicate Q_FOREACH loops [needing qAsConst()] ".

No idea why this foreach would work differently on Ubuntu 20.04.1, but here you go.

Thanks for your help anyway.

SGaist

Nice !

Glad you found out and thanks for sharing the results :-)

As for why, I do not know either, it's a pretty interesting bug.

JonB

@laurent-c said in Compilation of Qt5.3.1 on Ubuntu 20.04.1:

No idea why this foreach would work differently on Ubuntu 20.04

I imagine this is a compilation code issue. It's not the OS version per se, given the same Qt version it's that you're using a very different gcc version now from 6 years ago?

laurent.c

Just adding here what I found until I could fully compile Qt5.3.1.

I actually had to patch 3 other tools : moc, qdbusxml2cpp and uic which all had problems with foreach loops! I found the patches from the same person in the git repo of qtbase and adapted them to work on Qt5.3.1 source code.

Note that you also have to enable c++11 in order to compile with those patches. In buildroot-2015.05, this is done through package/qt5/qt5base/qt5base.mk by adding -c++11 flag to QT5BASE_CONFIGURE_CMDS (l. 163).

Then I could compile.

KasperO

@laurent-c Hi, I'm facing the same issue. Can you please share the patches you created or point to the patches you found in the git repo? Thanks.

publicNameWhatever

Assuming you run configure in qt source directory, you can specify QMAKEFEATURES like this:

QMAKEFEATURES=$PWD/qtbase/mkspecs/features \
./configure