executing query after cloned connection is used in another thread

[user4592357]

@sgaist
okay so it means i need to go back to my thread implementation
here's what i have

bool doWork(const QString &newVal)
{
     for (each of selected table rows)
     {
          if (!table->updateRow(row, newVal))
              return false;
          // QCoreApplication::processEvents();
     }
    return true;
}
bool Table::updateRow(int row, const QString &newVal)
{
     m_thread.execute(updateQuery, row, newVal);
     //...
}

when the processEvents is commented, the gui freezes, since the call to updateRow is executed in gui thread.
what should i do? put the for loop of doWork() in the thread? (the table is generic and in my case i need to update the database but another table might do something else where multithreaded update is not needed... although it won't hurt maybe)

[SGaist]

How proficient are you in the threading field ?

Because from the looks of it, you are directly calling methods on your thread class and expecting them to actually run in that other thread. It's not how it works.

[user4592357]

@sgaist
sorry for no context. i create the database and then use slots to execute the queries (because i want to execute the queries on some event, which is when the user decided to modify the data in my table widget).
roughly speaking, this is my implementation:

#pragma once

#include <QThread>
#include <QDebug>
#include <QtSql/QSqlError>
#include <QtSql/QSqlDatabase>
#include <QtSql/QSqlQuery>

class queryExecutor : public QObject
{
	Q_OBJECT
public:
	explicit queryExecutor(QObject *parent = nullptr) noexcept;

	void setDatabase(const QString &sDbPath);

public slots:
	void execute(const QString &query, const QHash<QString, QString> &mapBoundVals);

signals:
	void finished(bool success, const QList<QSqlRecord> &records);

private:
	QSqlDatabase m_db;
};

class QueryThread : public QThread
{
	Q_OBJECT
public:
	explicit QueryThread(const QString &sDbPath) noexcept;

protected:
	void run() override;

signals:
	void queryFinished(bool success, const QList<QSqlRecord> &records);

public slots:
	void execute(const QString &query, const QHash<QString, QString> &mapBoundVals);

private:
	queryExecutor m_queryExecutor;
	QString m_sDbPath;
};

queryExecutor::queryExecutor(QObject *parent /* = nullptr */) noexcept
{
}

void queryExecutor::setDatabase(const QString &sDbPath)
{
	// create a thread-specific connection
	m_db = QSqlDatabase::addDatabase("QSQLITE", QString("%1_%2")
		.arg(sDbPath)
		.arg(QString::number((quint64)QThread::currentThreadId(), 16)));

	qDebug() << "conn name" << QString("%1_%2")
		.arg(sDbPath)
		.arg(QString::number((quint64)QThread::currentThreadId(), 16));

	m_db.setDatabaseName(sDbPath);

	if (!m_db.open())
	{
		qDebug() << "db not open:" << m_db.lastError().text();
	}
}

void queryExecutor::execute(const QString &query, const QHash<QString, QString> &mapBoundVals)
{
	QList<QSqlRecord> records;
	QSqlQuery sqlQuery(m_db);
	sqlQuery.prepare(query);

	for (const auto &sPlaceholder : mapBoundVals.keys())
	{
		auto bound = mapBoundVals[sPlaceholder];
		sqlQuery.bindValue(sPlaceholder, bound);
	}

	if (!sqlQuery.exec())
	{
		qDebug() << "query failed:" << sqlQuery.lastError().text();
		emit finished(false, records);
		return;
	}

	while (sqlQuery.next())
		records.push_back(sqlQuery.record());

	emit finished(true, records);
}

QueryThread::QueryThread(const QString &sDbPath) noexcept
	: m_sDbPath(sDbPath)
{
}

void QueryThread::execute(const QString &query, const QHash<QString, QString> &mapBoundVals)
{
	// forward the execution to the worker
	m_queryExecutor.execute(query, mapBoundVals);
}

void QueryThread::run()
{
	qDebug() << "started thread" << QThread::currentThreadId();

	m_queryExecutor.setDatabase(m_sDbPath);

	// forward final signal
	connect(&m_queryExecutor, &queryExecutor::finished, this, &QueryThread::queryFinished);

	exec();
}

[Christian Ehrlicher]

Your function queryExecutor::execute() is not run in your thread since the slot from where it's called is a function from an object which lives in the main thread. I would suggest reading the QThread documentation on how to properly use Signals/Slots with QThread: https://doc.qt.io/qt-5/threads-qobject.html

[user4592357]

@christian-ehrlicher
yeah that's right. query executor should execute the query since it is in the new thread, so the code should be like this:

void QueryThread::execute(const QString &query, const QHash<QString, QString> &mapBoundVals)
{
	// forward the execution to the worker
	emit executefwd(query, mapBoundVals);
}

void QueryThread::run()
{
	qDebug() << "started thread" << QThread::currentThreadId();

	m_queryExecutor.setDatabase(m_sDbPath);

        connect( this, SIGNAL( executefwd( const QString&, const QHash<QString, QString> & ) ),
             m_queryExecutor, SLOT( execute( const QString&, const QHash<QString, QString> & ) ) );

	// forward final signal
	connect(&m_queryExecutor, &queryExecutor::finished, this, &QueryThread::queryFinished);

	exec();
}

[SGaist]

Your executor still lives in the main thread as it is created at your custom thread subclass creation time.

[user4592357]

@sgaist
oh okay, so it should be newed in QueryThread::run()

[SGaist]

It can be on the stack. It really depends on how you want to implement that stuff. You seem to be mixing the worker object approach with the subclass QThread approach.

[user4592357]

@sgaist
i followed this example for my implementation: https://www.linuxjournal.com/article/9602
but anyways i think thread is still not much helpful because my for loop still executes in main thread. am i right?

bool doWork(const QString &newVal)
{
     for (each of selected table rows)
     {
          if (!table->updateRow(row, newVal))
              return false;
     }
    return true;
}

bool Table::updateRow(int row, const QString &newVal)
{
     //update in another thread
}

[SGaist]

As already said, you are mixing two different technique the wrong way.

If you subclass QThread and re-implement run, then what is executed in run happens in the thread managed by QThread.

However, you created an instance of your worker object in the original thread since it's part of your QThread subclass and thus the slot will be executed in the original thread.