Client for VNC video streaming

ODБOï

Hi,
I don't know anything about VNC, while i'm searching on google i wanted to also ask on the forum if someone knows a way to 'listen' a VNC video streaming and save it to file with a Qt client.
Thank you very much for any hint.

mrjj

Hi
VNC is normally like
https://www.realvnc.com/en/
So im not sure what the video streaming part would be ?

Do you mean VLC ?
https://www.videolan.org/index.da.html

fcarney

It its VLC it can capture and record a stream itself. It also has an API to their DLLs that may be able to do the same thing. So it could be done using VLCs own libraries.

ODБOï

hi,

@mrjj said in Client for VNC video streaming:

So im not sure what the video streaming part would be ?

VNC is secure remote desktop access tool,
I don't need to display the ui when i'm accessing it remotely, i only need a program that will recive the video and save to file. I'm not sure it is possible
i need to search more about how it works

@fcarney thx i will check VLC libs for the screen capture if there is no possibilities to save to file without displaying on the screen.

thank you

fcarney

Oh, in that case it may be that VNC uses a proprietary stream rather than what VLC uses. VLC uses open streams designed for video streaming. It sounds like apples and oranges to me.

mrjj

Hi
Its very unclear to me what you ask about.
What will be streaming the video ? and what format ?

ODБOï

@mrjj
i don't know how VNC realy works,and it is unclear to me also.

I have pc1 with a 3rd party GUI application running,
with another pc2 i want to capture the gui of the first pc.

So pc2 can display/record pc1 screen with VNC, like with teamviewer. I want my qt app to run on pc2 and also record the screen of pc1.

thank you @mrjj

mrjj

@LeLev
Ah, ok, so you did mean VNC sort of way.
Well such tool exists
https://www.tightvnc.com/rfbplayer.php

However its not easy to rerecreate using a Qt app as you would have to to understand its protocol.
There does exists libs to use
https://libvnc.github.io/

However, can we talk about the goal of this ?
the other 3rd party GUI is runnig on some pc and you want to record a video of it running?
what will it be doing ?

ODБOï

Thank you,

@mrjj said in Client for VNC video streaming:

the other 3rd party GUI is runnig on some pc and you want to record a video of it running?

yes,it is running on a machine with 'custom windows'

the Gui will reveal a strange 'hardware' bug on the machine that happends only 1-2 times per year... lot of things have been done for debugging this (not by me) but nothing was found, everything is 'normal' :) . I need to record the gui to see some values when the 'hardware' bug happends. I could simply use Fraps or another screen capture tool, but the installation of 3rd party tool is not allowed on that windows. It has VNC

SGaist

Hi,

This article and the linked repository might be just what you need.

Hope it helps

mrjj

@LeLev

Ok, a rare bug. Delicious ;)
if it only happens 1-2 in a year, how will you know what time to record video?

Anyway, you could simply use a tool to record the VNC session then. im not sure creating a Qt app would be worth the time.

ODБOï

@mrjj said in Client for VNC video streaming:

Delicious ;)

absolutely! :) but this cost tons of money.. for the chief. that is a large machine going crazy once a year

i want my qt app to start every time when the user will start the machine (he will also start my app on a pc near the machine).
then my app will record and save video chunks. I thought using qt to handle record/chunk/deletion/.. logic
Do you think tools alre 'programables' enough or its worth use Qt (everywhere).
Thanks

mrjj

@LeLev
Ah, well even most tools can be controlled by scripts, using a Qt program would be more solid.
Also considering its the operator that controls the recording. ( i though it would be you)
it has to be really smooth operating so a Qt app seems like good idea.

How many FPS do you need to record ?

ODБOï

@mrjj said in Client for VNC video streaming:

Also considering its the operator that controls the recording. ( i though it would be you)

I need to minimize operator intervention. He will only start the pc the rest must be done automatically.

20-30 fps and descent ~480p+ is enough

mrjj

@LeLev

Ok, so it must auto connect and record and make sure not to fill disk with video.
The QVNCClientWidget should make it fairly easy to connect etc but
it seems not to have a direct way of save to video.
However, it exposes the image directly as QImage so you should be able to
create a video somehow.

ODБOï

@mrjj said in Client for VNC video streaming:

QVNCClientWidget

Really ?! awsome there is a ready to use Qt Class !
i was not expecting this conclusion at all
Thank you very much for info and for your time!
I will play with QVNCClientWidget this weekend and get into this monday.

mrjj

@LeLev
Hi
Yes, SGaist was so kind to dig one up. :) (see link higher up)
Its not part of official Qt but Qt never the less.
Its from 2016 so seems pretty recent.
So the biggest issue will be to produce a video from the frames. Preferable compressed
if video size matters.

ODБOï

@mrjj said in Client for VNC video streaming:

see link higher

cant find it,

https://bitbucket.org/amahta/qvncclient/src ?

mrjj

@LeLev
yep :)

ODБOï

@mrjj
perfect ! thank you and thank you @SGaist