What class or types can be used to do a real time image plot?

mrjj

Hi
The seismic wave animation might be an issue with the QtCharts/other plotting classes.
Do you plan to have much larger image ?
I was wondering if direct QImage manipulation would be fast enough and leaning towards a custom QPainter implementation.
http://doc.qt.io/qt-5/topics-graphics.html
For a full blown high speed solution, OpenGLWidget comes to mind.

How does the c code plot currently ? Direct screen buffer ?

Flavio Mesquita

@mrjj Hi, at the moment it doesn´t plot, it just creates a .bin file every 500 iterations and we have to use some other software to load and show the static image, I saw something similar done with python that plots in realtime, the guy put the plot inside the loop, and everytime the code makes a iteration it refreshes the plot.
But my code will have to be implemented with C++ because we need performance, even planning on using OpenACC directives. I believe we cannot implement OpenACC with Qt, so I may use an interface made with Qt for setting the parameters, call the program, pick the input file etc. I have the idea of creating the .bin files with less iterations, maybe 100, then create a Qt program that could read these files from the folder and plot it as they are created. Not sure if it is the best solution.

mrjj

@Flavio-Mesquita said in What class or types can be used to do a real time image plot?:

OpenACC

Well i think you can use it with Qt but it dubious you get accelerated gpu drawing out of the box if even possible.
If the .bin files are some sort of image format ( like raw) , it might be possible to
load with QImage and draw it.
When you say , "need performance" is that on the data reading part or on the plotting part ?
Unless saving to ramdisk, the slowest link will be the IO for the bin files.

so goal is not live plotting but saving to bin files for later viewing?

Flavio Mesquita

@mrjj By performance I mean on the processing part, the Reverse Time Migration is quite heavy computationaly. If I use a simple input file, that is the subsurface velocity model, it is quick, lets say matter of few minutes, but if it is complicated it can take hours. Maybe live plotting is not necessary, if I have an application that keeps checking if there is a new raw .bin file on the folder and plot it, would solve the problem. So, u think QImage and Qpainter could do the job? The .bin files are not big, it ranges from 1 to 20 Mb.

mrjj

@Flavio-Mesquita
Ok, so the c++ speed gain would come from using threads?
If the data input for QImage is only 20mb-ish i think it can handle it pretty well
but it depends on your expected fps and the output size and how much pre-processing of the bin data is
need before QImage will load it.
It had pretty good speed with 640x480 images.

Flavio Mesquita

@mrjj said in What class or types can be used to do a real time image plot?:

It had pretty good speed with 640x480 images.

This size is perfect for me, do u have any examples of Qimage usage? Any book, tutorial, anything?

SGaist

Hi,

Depending on what you need, did you consider using maybe CUDA with OpenGL to generate the images you want to show ?

In any case, there are lots of examples using QImage in the Qt documentation. Depending on your needs the Mandelbrot example might be of interest.

mrjj

@Flavio-Mesquita
The docs are pretty good.
Basically it allows direct access and depending on the format of bin files you need something like

QImage* img = new QImage(640, 480, QImage::Format_RGB16);
for (int y = 0; y < img->height(); y++)
{
    memcpy(img->scanLine(y), BinData[y], img->bytesPerLine());
}
...

This is just pseudo code. Read about scanLine and friends in Docs
QImage::Format_RGB16 is just one of several so there might be other that
are closer to the .bin format layout.

Its a often asked question on StackOverflow and also here
https://forum.qt.io/topic/70653/how-to-display-8-bit-grayscale-raw-image-to-a-qlabel-and-display-it-in-x11-board

but since i have zero idea of what your .bin contains its harder to suggest something direct.
You most likely need to process the .bin to actually display it correctly.

Flavio Mesquita

@SGaist Hi, we considered using CUDA, but it is more complicated than OpenACC. We will give a try with it anyway to compare, I know it has better performance than OpenAcc, just don´t know how much better.

Flavio Mesquita

@mrjj Thanks, I´ll take a look at these examples and references, I´ll be coming with more questions soon. First thing is to put the code to run properly with C++. The interface I already have. Now it is just a matter of adapt the RTM code., when everything is set and running I´ll start the work on the plotting part.
Cheers

mrjj

@Flavio-Mesquita
Good plan.
also IF raw painting is too slow, its not too late there to go openGL or
anything accelerated