How to read registry binary data using QT?

[Narasimman]

Checked already I am not getting info for reading the binary data, all other i am able to read

[Ratzz]

@Narasimman
Something like this?

    QSettings reg("HKEY_CURRENT_USER\\Environment", QSettings::NativeFormat);
    QString stringg = reg.value("TEST").toString();
    QByteArray data = QByteArray((const char*)stringg.utf16());
    qDebug() << "value : " << data;

[jsulm]

@Narasimman @Ratzz I would say (since QString isn't binary):

QSettings reg("HKEY_CURRENT_USER\\Environment", QSettings::NativeFormat);
QByteArray data = reg.value("TEST").toByteArray();
qDebug() << "value : " << data;

[Narasimman]

@jsulm said in How to read registry binary data using QT?:

qDebug() << "value : " << data;

QSettings Drives("HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\MountedDevices",QSettings::NativeFormat);

QStringList keys = Drives.allKeys();
qDebug()<<"jeys list :"<<keys.count();

for(int i=0;i<keys.count();i++)
{
    QString strkey = keys.at(i);
    qDebug()<<"Key: "<<strkey;
    QVariant strvalue=Drives.value(strkey);
    QByteArray data = Drives.value(strkey).toByteArray();
    qDebug() << "valuebyte : " << data;
    qDebug()<<"Value Type : "<<strvalue.type()<<" name : "<<strvalue.typeName()<<" value :"<<strvalue.toByteArray().toStdString().c_str();

}

This is my code.

Below are the output of the above code

[Key: "#{f6d859dc-538d-11e7-81fe-f85971670abf}"]
[valuebyte : "\xE4\xB5\x84\xE4\xBD\x89\xE4\xA4\xBA\xE3\xA9\x84\xE6\xBB\x99\xEE\xBC\xB9\xE1\xA3\x9F\xE4\xA4\x8A\xE8\xBA\xA9\xEB\xBF\x8B\xE5\xBC\xB0\xE3\x88\x88"]
[Value Type : QVariant::QString name : QString value : ????????????]
[Key: "/??/Volume{0040c5a3-3c8c-11e8-8216-54e1ad32fe3b}"]
[valuebyte : ""]
[Value Type : QVariant::Invalid name : value : ]
[Key: "/??/Volume{1eb29a46-1878-11e8-8211-54e1ad32fe3b}"]
[valuebyte : ""]

But still not getting the value. Let me know what is the issue ?

[jsulm]

@Narasimman
Here you got binary:
[Key: "#{f6d859dc-538d-11e7-81fe-f85971670abf}"]
[valuebyte : "\xE4\xB5\x84\xE4\xBD\x89\xE4\xA4\xBA\xE3\xA9\x84\xE6\xBB\x99\xEE\xBC\xB9\xE1\xA3\x9F\xE4\xA4\x8A\xE8\xBA\xA9\xEB\xBF\x8B\xE5\xBC\xB0\xE3\x88\x88"]

Here the content is a string and you should treat it as string:
[Value Type : QVariant::QString name : QString value : ????????????]
[Key: "/??/Volume{0040c5a3-3c8c-11e8-8216-54e1ad32fe3b}"]
[valuebyte : ""]

Here you got something invalid:
[Value Type : QVariant::Invalid name : value : ]
[Key: "/??/Volume{1eb29a46-1878-11e8-8211-54e1ad32fe3b}"]
[valuebyte : ""]

[Narasimman]

@jsulm said in How to read registry binary data using QT?:

@Narasimman
Here you got binary:
[Key: "#{f6d859dc-538d-11e7-81fe-f85971670abf}"]
[valuebyte : "\xE4\xB5\x84\xE4\xBD\x89\xE4\xA4\xBA\xE3\xA9\x84\xE6\xBB\x99\xEE\xBC\xB9\xE1\xA3\x9F\xE4\xA4\x8A\xE8\xBA\xA9\xEB\xBF\x8B\xE5\xBC\xB0\xE3\x88\x88"]

Below all the registry keys are of same type as binary , why i got 1 as string another a binary, no clue on this.

Here the content is a string and you should treat it as string:
[Value Type : QVariant::QString name : QString value : ????????????]
[Key: "/??/Volume{0040c5a3-3c8c-11e8-8216-54e1ad32fe3b}"]
[valuebyte : ""]

Here you got something invalid:
[Value Type : QVariant::Invalid name : value : ]
[Key: "/??/Volume{1eb29a46-1878-11e8-8211-54e1ad32fe3b}"]
[valuebyte : ""]

[jsulm]

@Narasimman How do these binary keys look in regedit.exe?

[Narasimman]

Above is the screeshot of the registry key.

[Narasimman]

Any update on this ?

[Ratzz]

@Narasimman @jsulm
I just noticed

   QSettings reg("HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\\SYSTEM\\DriverDatabase", QSettings::NativeFormat);

    QString stringg = reg.value("OemInfMap").toString();
    QByteArray data = QByteArray((const char*)stringg.utf16());
    qDebug() << "value using QString : " << data;

    QByteArray byteArray = reg.value("OemInfMap").toByteArray();
    qDebug() << "value using QByteArray : " << byteArray;

Gives me

value using QString :  "\xFF\xFF\xFF\xF0"
value using QByteArray :  "\xEF\xBF\xBF\xEF\x83\xBF"

[jsulm]

@Ratzz said in How to read registry binary data using QT?:

QByteArray data = QByteArray((const char*)stringg.utf16());

This is simply wrong. If it is binary already then do

QByteArray data = reg.value("OemInfMap").toByteArray();

Do NOT convert binary data to string, then to Unicode string and then to binary again!

[Ratzz]

@jsulm

QByteArray data = reg.value("OemInfMap").toByteArray();

With this why don't I get exact binary data??

[Devopia53]

@Ratzz

You ar right. The REG_BINARY type is converted to QString. But there is a bug. If the length of the binary data is odd, the last data is truncated.

in qsettings_win.cpp, line 547, Qt 5.10.0
s = QString::fromWCharArray((const wchar_t *)data.constData(), data.size() / 2);

[jsulm]

@Ratzz Yes, just tested - QVariant contains a string, I expected it to contain QByteArray for binary data.

[JonB]

@Devopia53 said in How to read registry binary data using QT?:

@Ratzz

You ar right. The REG_BINARY type is converted to QString. But there is a bug. If the length of the binary data is odd, the last data is truncated.

in qsettings_win.cpp, line 547, Qt 5.10.0
s = QString::fromWCharArray((const wchar_t *)data.constData(), data.size() / 2);

This in itself is not a bug. A "wide char array" is an array of bytes in which each pair represents one character. Therefore the length must be even, and the code is as correct as it can be.

If the data is arbitrary bytes, as it seems to be, it should never be treated as a wide char array/QString.

I don't know, but does (unfixed) https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/QTBUG-98 imply this is simply still not doable in Qt5?

It could be an enhancement to QSettings to support more registry types which are correctly mapped in the QVariant. Qt should map REG_BINARY to QByteArray

We can't fix this until Qt 5, because REG_BINARY is currently read by QSettings as a utf-16 encoded QString. Changing this would break existing applications.

Naughty, naughty!

[Devopia53]

@JonB

I also know about Wide-char. If it's a problem with Wide-char, that's right. However, it is a problem that REG_BINARY type is converted to QString without used QByteArray.

[JonB]

@Devopia53
See my extra typings in my post.

[Devopia53]

@JonB

Yes I have known the problem for a long time. So, in this case, I use Windows API to handle it directly.

[JonB]

@Devopia53
So far as I can see, your approach is indeed required at present. The OP needs to use a native Windows registry call to deal correctly with the data. Perhaps you'd be kind enough to give him a skeleton nudge in this direction for what you wrote to do so?

[aha_1980]

Hi @Devopia53

there is even a report for this: https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/QTBUG-52960