Q_PROPERTY clarification

Mark81

This does not compile. If I try:

this->setCounterInTotal(0)

the build fails with:

error: ‘class MyClass’ has no member named ‘setCounterInTotal’
     this->setCounterInTotal(0);
           ^

SGaist

Hi,

AFAIK, MEMBER triggers moc to generate additional code that enables the access to the property through the meta object system i.e. what's is used to interface with QML. If you want to modify the properties through C++, then you can use the setProperty method.

kshegunov

Please show current (exact code) and also say if you reran qmake and rebuilt.

@SGaist said in Q_PROPERTY clarification:

If you want to modify the properties through C++, then you can use the setProperty method.

MEMBER should generate the read and write accessor functions for the property, so it's not only to expose it to QML.

Mark81

I can't post the code (like the above...) because when I click "submit" the website tells me the content was flagged as spam!
This happens even if I discard and create a new reply...

Mark81

Here my complete test code:

myclass.h

class MyClass : public QObject
{
    Q_OBJECT

public:
    explicit MyClass(QObject *parent = nullptr);

    Q_PROPERTY(qreal counterInTotal MEMBER _counterInTotal NOTIFY counterInTotalChanged)

private:
    qreal _counterInTotal;

signals:
    void counterInTotalChanged(qreal);

};

myclass.c
#include "myclass.h"

MyClass::MyClass(QObject *parent) : QObject(parent)
{
    this->setCounterInTotal(0);
}

Run qmake. Run build:

myclass.cpp:5: error: ‘class MyClass’ has no member named ‘setCounterInTotal’
     this->setCounterInTotal(0);
           ^

I'm using Qt5.9.2 under Debian cross-compiled for ARM.

Mark81

@Mark81 I had to remove the #ifdef to post it.

kshegunov

Indeed, it seems @SGaist is correct and I'm wrong. I could've sworn it used to generate the accessor functions. Anyway, in light of that, I have to say you need to write them manually ...

Apparently I have lived in a parallel universe:
See here https://forum.qt.io/topic/29072/solved-use-of-q_property-s-member-keyword-outside-of-qml

Mark81

No problem.
I knew that thread but I was hoping Qt guys had fixed that after five years!

Of course manually writing getter/setter functions work as expected. It's just a bit tedious if you have lot of properties!

mranger90

Is it because the "MEMBER _counterInTotal" has an underscore ?

kshegunov

@mranger90 said in Q_PROPERTY clarification:

Is it because the "MEMBER _counterInTotal" has an underscore ?

Nope, not really. It just never generated the functions, it seems to have been some kind of urban legend ... :)