Offer me a good QML exercise

[tomy]

@J.Hilk
Thanks.
I tried to make the work done and here is the code.
I don't use the prior versions of the code (above) but this one.

Ball.qml and Racket.qml are as before but main.qml is completely as below.

As you see I haven't used a function and I don't know if it's needed or not.
If possible please run that code to see its function. I don't think it's flawless.
The code also to me is very messy. If it can make the work done using little changes, what to do for removing the problems from that please?

import QtQuick 2.8
import QtQuick.Window 2.2

Window {
    visible: true
    width: 800
    height: 600
    title: qsTr("The PingPong Game")

    Rectangle {
        id: table
        width: 700; height: 500
        border.width: 10
        border.color: "black"
        color: "royalblue"

   Racket {
       id: redRacket
       x: 630; y: 100
       color: "red"
       property int  rOldy: y
       property bool rYmovement: false
       onYChanged: {
           rYmovement = y - rOldy < 0 ? true : false
           rOldy = y
       }
   }

   Racket {
       id: blackRacket
       x: 50; y: 100
       color: "black"
       property int  bOldy: y
       property bool bYmovement: false
       onYChanged: {
           bYmovement = y - bOldy < 0 ? true : false
           bOldy = y
       }
   }

   Ball {
       id: ball
       x: table.width/2 - 50
       y: table.height/2
       property double ran: Math.random() + 0.5
       property double xincrement: ran
       property double yincrement: ran
   }

   Column {
       spacing: 3
       x: table.width/2
       y: 10
          Repeater {
            model: 21
             delegate: Rectangle {
                      width: 5
                      height: 20
                      color: "white"
                   }
             }
       }

   Timer {
     interval: 15; repeat: true; running: true

        onTriggered: {
            ball.x = ball.x + (ball.xincrement * 2.0);
            ball.y = ball.y + (ball.yincrement * 2.0);

            if((ball.x + ball.width  >= redRacket.x)  &&
              ((ball.y + ball.height >= redRacket.y)  &&
               (ball.y + ball.height <= redRacket.y + redRacket.height)))
                if(redRacket.rYmovement) {
                     ball.yincrement *= -1
                     ball.xincrement *= -1
                    redRacket.rYmovement = false
                   }
                 else ball.xincrement *= -1

            if((ball.x - ball.width  <= blackRacket.x)  &&
              ((ball.y + ball.height >= blackRacket.y)  &&
               (ball.y + ball.height <= blackRacket.y + blackRacket.height)))
                if(blackRacket.bYmovement) {
                     ball.yincrement *= -1
                     ball.xincrement *= -1
                    blackRacket.bYmovement = false
                   }
                 else ball.xincrement *= -1

             if(ball.y <= 0 || ball.y + ball.height >= table.height)
                  ball.yincrement *= -1
           }
       }
    }
 }

[J.Hilk]

@tomy

to make it a bit cleaner, if you for example moved some stuff to the Ball and Racket qml-files

//Racket
import QtQuick 2.8

Rectangle {
    id: root
    width: 15; height: 50
    x: 400; y: 100
    color: "red"

    property int oldY: y
    property bool yMovement: false
    onYChanged: {
        yMovement = y - oldY < 0 ? true : false
        oldY = y
    }

    MouseArea {
        anchors.fill: parent
        drag.target: root
        drag.axis: Drag.YAxis
        drag.minimumY: 10
        drag.maximumY: 440
    }
}

//Ball.qml
import QtQuick 2.8

Rectangle {
    width: 20; height: 20
    x: 250; y: 250
    color: "white"
    radius: width/2

    property double ran: Math.random() + 0.5
    property double xincrement: ran
    property double yincrement: ran
}

Besides that I don't see what the problem is, theres at least 1 bug I run into whilst playing, x) but thats part of coding.

If you thinks the animation is a but stuttery thats to be expected, you replaced a propertyanimation with a Timer and x/y changes.

I believe, PropertyAnimation does some internal stuff to make the animation as smooth as possible, a change each refresh frame e.g. Where as with a timer aproeach you are fixed to 5 ms updates and in that you only increase the distance the ball is moved. That gonna look like jumps eventually ;-)

[tomy]

@J.Hilk

I replaced the PropertyAnimation with Timer because I didn't know how to achieve what I have now without Timer but with PropertyAnimation.
The Timer works fine with smoothness but in this example I'd changed the interval from 2 to 15 to slow the movement of the ball for better testing.

The game has defects even in this point unfortunately. And it's the feature of targeting.
The if(redRacket.rYmovement) conditions code don't work as expected. I should think over them so that they work as needed.
But a question here, does the y coordinate change relate to the "last" movement of the racket before the ball hits it?

[J.Hilk]

@tomy

I changed the timer stuff a bit, to make it more readable, what happens

   Timer {
     interval: 15; repeat: true; running: true

     function hitsRightRacket(){
         if(ball.x +ball.width >= redRacket.x  && ball.x < redRacket.x + redRacket.width){
             if(ball.y >= redRacket.y && ball.y <= redRacket.y+redRacket.height)
                 return true
         }
         return false
     }

     function hitsLeftRacket(){
         if(ball.x +ball.width >= blackRacket.x  && ball.x < blackRacket.x + blackRacket.width){
             if(ball.y >= blackRacket.y && ball.y <= blackRacket.y+blackRacket.height)
                 return true
         }
         return false
     }

     function hitsRightWall(){
         if(ball.x +ball.width >= table.width)
             return true
         else
             return false
     }

     function hitsLeftWall(){
         if(ball.x <= 0)
             return true
         else
             return false
     }

     function hitsUpperOrLowerWall(){
         if(ball.y <= 0 || ball.y + ball.height >= table.height)
              return true
         return false
     }

     property bool lastHitLeft: false
     property bool lastHitRight: false

        onTriggered: {
            if(hitsRightWall()){
                console.log("Point Left Side")
                running = false
            }else if(hitsLeftWall()){
                console.log("Point Right Side")
                running = false
            }else if(hitsLeftRacket() && !lastHitLeft){
                console.log("Hits Black Racket",blackRacket.yMovement)
                lastHitLeft = true
                lastHitRight = false
                if(blackRacket.yMovement){
                    ball.yincrement *= -1
                    ball.xincrement *= -1
                 }else
                    ball.xincrement *= -1
            }else if(hitsRightRacket() && !lastHitRight){
                console.log("Hits Red Racket",redRacket.yMovement)
                lastHitLeft = false
                lastHitRight = true
                if(redRacket.yMovement) {
                     ball.yincrement *= -1
                     ball.xincrement *= -1
                   }
                 else ball.xincrement *= -1
            }else if(hitsUpperOrLowerWall())
                ball.yincrement *= -1

            //Move Ball
            ball.x = ball.x + (ball.xincrement * 2.0);
            ball.y = ball.y + (ball.yincrement * 2.0);
           }
       }

This showed me that you'll need a better case handleing for ball movement and racket movement,

• ball moves towards y = 0 and Racket moves towards y = 0
• ball moves towards y = 0 and Racket moves towards y = table height
• ball moves towards y = table and Racket moves towards y = 0
• ball moves towards y = table Racket moves towards y = table height

currently you're only checking in what direction the racket moved,

[tomy]

@J.Hilk
Hi,
Thank you for your assistance.

If we divide the task into part I and II, the first part I think is almost done! Please take a look at the code below and if possible please run the program on your system. It works fine for me.

In part I, I need two extra components I think: one, a series of buttons for starting, resuming and finishing the game when it's not over yet. And second, some sound for goals and when a player wins the game.
If we can complete part I, I assume part II will be about networking! :)

Ball.qml:

import QtQuick 2.9

Rectangle {
    width: 12; height: 12
    x: 250; y: 250
    color: "white"
    radius: width/2
    property double ran: Math.random() + 0.5
    property double xincrement: ran
    property double yincrement: ran
}

Counter.qml:

import QtQuick 2.9

Rectangle {
    width: 40; height: 50
    color: "lightskyblue"
    property int count: 0

    Text {
        id: text
        anchors.centerIn: parent
        text: count.toString()
        color: "gray"
        font.bold: true
        font.pixelSize: 30
    }
}

Light.qml:

import QtQuick 2.9

Rectangle {
    width: 50; height: 50
    border.width: 5
    border.color: "silver"
    radius: width/2
    property bool start: false
}

Racket.qml:

import QtQuick 2.9

Rectangle {
    id: root
    width: 12; height: 40
    property int oldY: y
    property bool yUwards: false
    property bool yDwards: false

       onYChanged: {
           if(y > oldY)
               yDwards = true
           else if (y < oldY)
               yUwards = true
           oldY = y
       }

    MouseArea {
        anchors.fill: parent
        drag.target: root
        drag.axis: Drag.YAxis
        drag.minimumY: table.y - 20
        drag.maximumY: table.y + table.height - 60
    }
}

WinBox.qml:

import QtQuick 2.9

Text {
     width: 50; height: 50
     text: "WINNER"
     color: "royalblue"
     font.bold: true
     font.pixelSize: 40
     visible: false
}

main.qml:

import QtQuick 2.9
import QtQuick.Window 2.2

Window {
    visible: true
    width: 820
    height: 620
    title: qsTr("The PingPong Game")
    color: "gray"

    Rectangle {
        x: 10; y: 10
        width: 800; height: 500
        color: "white"
    }

    Rectangle {
        id: table
        x: 20; y: 20
        width: 780; height: 480
        color: "royalblue"
        property int count: 1
        property bool turn: false
        property bool lightState: false

        Racket {
            id: redRacket
            x: table.width - 30; y: 100
            color: "red"
        }

        Racket {
            id: blackRacket
            x: table.x; y: 100
            color: "black"
        }

        Ball {
            id: ball
            x: table.width/2
            y: table.height/2
        }

        Column {
            spacing: 3
            x: table.width/2
            Repeater {
                model: 21
                delegate: Rectangle {
                    width: 5
                    height: 20
                    color: "white"
                }
            }
        }

        Counter {
            id: rightCounter
            x: table.width / 2 + 90
            y: 50
        }

        Counter {
            id: leftCounter
            x: table.width / 4 + 70
            y: 50
        }

        Light {
            id: rightLight
            x: table.width/2 + 80
            y: table.height + 20
            color: "silver"
        }

        Light {
            id: leftLight
            x: table.width/2 - 120
            y: table.height + 20
            color: "lime"
        }

        WinBox {
            id: rightWin
            x: table.width/2 + 160
            y: table.height + 40
        }

        WinBox {
            id: leftWin
            x: table.width/2 - 350
            y: table.height + 40
        }

        Timer {
            interval: 40; repeat: true; running: true

            onTriggered: {
                redRacket.yUwards = false
                redRacket.yDwards = false
                blackRacket.yUwards = false
                blackRacket.yDwards = false
            }
        }

        Timer {
            id: out_timer
            interval: 1; repeat: false; running: false

            function lightChange() {
                if (table.lightState) {
                    rightLight.color = "silver"
                    leftLight.color= "lime"
                  }

                else {
                    rightLight.color = "lime"
                    leftLight.color= "silver"
                  }
                table.lightState = !table.lightState
            }

            onTriggered: {
                ball.xincrement = Math.random() + 0.5
                ball.yincrement = Math.random() + 0.5

                if( table.count % 5 == 0) {
                    table.turn = !table.turn
                    lightChange()
                }


                 if(table.turn)
                    ball.xincrement *= -1

                ball.x = table.width/2
                ball.y = table.height/2

                if (ball.yincrement > 1.1)
                    ball.yincrement *= -1

                in_timer.restart()
                table.count++
            }
        }

        Timer {
            id: in_timer
            interval: duration; repeat: true; running: true
            property int duration: 2

            function hitsRightWall() {
                if (ball.x + ball.width >= table.width)
                    return true
                else return false
            }

            function hitsLeftWall() {
                if(ball.x <= 0) return true
                else return false
            }

            property bool lastHitLeft: false
            property bool lastHitRight: false

            onTriggered: {

                if(hitsRightWall()) {
                    in_timer.stop()
                    leftCounter.count++
                    out_timer.interval = 2000
                    out_timer.running = true
                }

                else if(hitsLeftWall()) {
                    in_timer.stop()
                    rightCounter.count++
                    out_timer.interval = 2000
                    out_timer.running = true
                }

                ball.x = ball.x + (ball.xincrement * 2.0);
                ball.y = ball.y + (ball.yincrement * 2.0);

                if ((ball.x + ball.width >= redRacket.x  &&
                     ball.x < redRacket.x + redRacket.width / 3) &&
                        (ball.y + ball.height >= redRacket.y - 10 &&
                         ball.y <= redRacket.y + redRacket.height))
                {
                    if(redRacket.yUwards) {
                        if(ball.yincrement == 0)
                            ball.yincrement = -ball.ran
                        else if(ball.yincrement > 0)
                            ball.yincrement *= -1
                        interval = duration/2
                    }
                    else if (redRacket.yDwards) {
                        if(ball.yincrement == 0)
                            ball.yincrement = ball.ran
                        else if(ball.yincrement < 0)
                            ball.yincrement *= -1
                        interval = duration/2
                    }
                    else {
                        ball.yincrement = 0
                        interval = duration
                    }

                    ball.xincrement *= -1
                }

                if ((ball.x + ball.width >= blackRacket.x &&
                     ball.x < blackRacket.x + blackRacket.width)  &&
                        (ball.y + ball.height >= blackRacket.y &&
                         ball.y <= blackRacket.y + blackRacket.height))
                {
                    if(blackRacket.yUwards) {
                        if(ball.yincrement == 0)
                            ball.yincrement = -ball.ran
                        else if(ball.yincrement > 0)
                            ball.yincrement *= -1
                        interval = duration/2
                    }
                    else if (blackRacket.yDwards) {
                        if(ball.yincrement == 0)
                            ball.yincrement = ball.ran
                        else if(ball.yincrement < 0)
                            ball.yincrement *= -1
                        interval = duration/2
                    }
                    else {
                        ball.yincrement = 0
                        interval = duration
                    }

                    ball.xincrement *= -1
                }

                if(ball.x <= 0 || ball.x + ball.width >= table.width)
                    ball.xincrement *= (-1);

                if(ball.y <= 0 || ball.y + ball.height >= table.height)
                    ball.yincrement *= -1

                if(rightCounter.count + leftCounter.count == 21) {
                       in_timer.stop()
                    if(rightCounter.count > leftCounter.count)
                        rightWin.visible = true
                    else if (rightCounter.count < leftCounter.count)
                        leftWin.visible = true
                    else {
                        rightWin.visible = true
                        leftWin.visible = true
                    }
                }
            }            
        }
    }
}

[J.Hilk]

Looks great! You're defenitly on the right track.

However I have a bug to report. I managed to catch the ball in the racket. That's the reasdon why I introtuced the 2 properties lastHitLeft and lastHitRight in my previous post. You still have them in your code, but they are not used.

[tomy]

@J.Hilk
Hi, thanks.

Well, I laid those factors and ran the code. Unfortunately it made the issue more prominent! The ball passes through the ball obliquely.

So I think I must return back to the version without them and the issue is subtle! It happens when a racket tries to hit the ball from the top/down moving downwards/upwards and the ball gets stuck in the upper/lower edge of the racket. I think I should work on this.

Previously I was thinking of making the racket thinner to prevent this bug. But I try to find a more logical way.

[tomy]

Hi,

For a while I was trying to use contains(point p), mapFromItem(...) or mapToItem(...). But unfortunately, no success! So I got back to the prior method, which was using the X and Y coordinates as follows.

Please run it on your system. It works fine for me. The bug is also solved.
But there's another bug!

• Moving the racket when playing the game on the Desktop kit (Windows) doesn't affect the speed of ball's movement but when run on an Android device, moving the racket affects the speed of ball's movement as though their movements have been tied together.

I also tried to manipulate the MouseArea in the Racket.qml to cope with that, but no change in the result! :(

Please check it and express your idea how to solve that issue.

QML files Ball, Counter, Light and Winbox are as before.

Racket.qml:

import QtQuick 2.9

Rectangle {
    id: root
    width: 15; height: 65
    property int oldY: y
    property bool yUwards: false
    property bool yDwards: false

    onYChanged: {
        if(y > oldY)  yDwards = true
        else if (y < oldY)  yUwards = true
        oldY = y
    }

    MouseArea {
        anchors.fill: parent
        anchors.margins: -root.height
        drag.target: root
        focus: true
        hoverEnabled: true
        pressAndHoldInterval: 0
        drag.axis: Drag.YAxis
        drag.minimumY: table.y
        drag.maximumY: table.height - root.height - 10
    }
}

main.qml:

import QtQuick 2.9
import QtQuick.Window 2.2
import QtQuick.Controls 2.1

Window {
    id: window
    visibility: Window.Maximized
    title: qsTr("The PingPong Game - A QML Game")
    color: "gray"
    
    Rectangle {
        id: table
        width: window.width / 1.15; height: window.height / 1.15
        x: window.x + 100; y: 10;
        border.width: 10
        border.color: "white"
        color: "royalblue"
        property int count: 1
        property bool turn: false
        property bool lightState: false
        property double step: 3.0
        property int duration: 4
        
        Racket {
            id: blackRacket
            anchors.left: table.left
            anchors.leftMargin: width * 2
            y: height
            color: "black"
        }
        Racket {
            id: redRacket
            anchors.right: table.right
            anchors.rightMargin: width * 2
            y: height
            color: "red"
        }
        
        
        Ball {
            id: ball
            x: table.width/2
            y: table.height/2
        }
        
        Column {
            spacing: 3
            anchors.centerIn: table
            anchors.top: table.top
            Repeater {
                model: table.height/(blackRacket.height / 2 + 3)
                delegate: Rectangle {
                    width: 5
                    height: blackRacket.height / 2
                    color: "white"
                }
            }
        }
        
        Counter {
            id: leftCounter
            x: table.width / 2 - height - 100
            y: 50
        }
        Counter {
            id: rightCounter
            x: table.width / 2 + 100
            y: 50
        }
        
        
        Light {
            id: leftLight
            x: table.width/2 - 280
            y: table.height + 10
            color: "lime"
        }
        Light {
            id: rightLight
            x: table.width/2 + 220
            y: table.height + 10
            color: "silver"
        }
        
        WinBox {
            id: rightWin
            x: table.width/2 + 380
            y: table.height + 10
        }
        WinBox {
            id: leftWin
            x: table.x + 40
            y: table.height + 10
        }
        
        Button {
            x: table.width/2 - 45
            y: table.height + 10
            
            contentItem: Text {
                id: st_tx
                horizontalAlignment: Text.AlignHCenter
                verticalAlignment: Text.AlignVCenter
                text: qsTr("START")
                font.bold: true
                font.pixelSize: 20
                color: "green"
            }
            background: Rectangle {
                implicitHeight: 60
                implicitWidth: 100
                color: "lightGrey"
                border.width: 8
                border.color: "lightBlue"
                radius: 20
            }
            onClicked: table.startGame()
        }
        Button {
            x: table.width/2 - 150
            y: table.height + 10
            
            contentItem: Text {
                id: pu_tx
                horizontalAlignment: Text.AlignHCenter
                verticalAlignment: Text.AlignVCenter
                text: qsTr("PAUSE")
                font.bold: true
                font.pixelSize: 20
                color: "green"
            }
            background: Rectangle {
                id: pu_rec
                implicitHeight: 60
                implicitWidth: 100
                color: "lightGrey"
                border.width: 8
                border.color: "lightBlue"
                radius: 20
            }
            onClicked: table.pauseGame()
        }
        Button {
            x: table.width/2 + 60
            y: table.height + 10
            
            contentItem: Text {
                id: sp_tx
                horizontalAlignment: Text.AlignHCenter
                verticalAlignment: Text.AlignVCenter
                text: qsTr("STOP")
                font.bold: true
                font.pixelSize: 20
                color: "green"
            }
            background: Rectangle {
                implicitHeight: 60
                implicitWidth: 100
                color: "lightGrey"
                border.width: 8
                border.color: "lightBlue"
                radius: 20
                
            }
            onClicked: table.stopGame()
        }
        
        Text {
            x: window.x; y: table.height + 50
            color: "white"
            text: "Ver: 1.1"
            font.family: "Helvetica"
            font.pointSize: 15
        }
        Text {
            x: table.width - 200; y: table.height + 50
            color: "white"
            text: " Programmed By S.R. Abbasi (Tomy)"
            font.family: "Helvetica"
            font.pointSize: 10
        }
        
        function startGame() {
            st_tx.text = qsTr("START")
            if (leftWin.visible)
                leftWin.visible = false
            if (rightWin.visible)
                rightWin.visible = false
            in_timer.restart()
        }
        function pauseGame() {
            st_tx.text = qsTr("RESUME")
            in_timer.running = false
        }
        function stopGame() {
            st_tx.text = qsTr("START")
            in_timer.running = false
            rightCounter.count = 0
            leftCounter.count = 0
            ball.x = table.width/2
            ball.y = table.height/2
            table.count = 1
            table.turn = false
            rightLight.color = "silver"
            leftLight.color = "lime"
            
            if(ball.xincrement < 0 )
                ball.xincrement *= -1
        }
        
        Timer {
            interval: 40; repeat: true; running: true
            
            onTriggered: {
                redRacket.yUwards = false
                redRacket.yDwards = false
                blackRacket.yUwards = false
                blackRacket.yDwards = false
            }
        }
        Timer {
            id: out_timer
            interval: 1; repeat: false; running: false
            
            function lightChange() {
                if (table.lightState) {
                    rightLight.color = "silver"
                    leftLight.color= "lime"
                }
                else {
                    rightLight.color = "lime"
                    leftLight.color= "silver"
                }
                table.lightState = !table.lightState
            }
            
            onTriggered: {
                ball.xincrement = Math.random() + 0.5
                ball.yincrement = Math.random() + 0.5
                
                if (table.count % 5 == 0) {
                    table.turn = !table.turn
                    lightChange()
                }
                
                if (table.turn)
                    ball.xincrement *= -1
                
                ball.x = table.width/2
                ball.y = table.height/2
                
                if (ball.yincrement > 1.1)
                    ball.yincrement *= -1
                
                in_timer.restart()
                table.count++
            }
        }
        Timer {
            id: right_return_timer
            interval: 1; repeat: true; running: false
            onTriggered: {
                ball.x = ball.x + (ball.xincrement * table.step)
                ball.y = ball.y + (ball.yincrement * table.step)
                if(ball.x + ball.width < redRacket.x) {
                    running = false
                    in_timer.running = true
                }
            }
        }
        Timer {
            id: left_return_timer
            interval: 1; repeat: true; running: false
            onTriggered: {
                ball.x = ball.x + (ball.xincrement * table.step)
                ball.y = ball.y + (ball.yincrement * table.step)
                if(ball.x > blackRacket.x + blackRacket.width) {
                    running = false
                    in_timer.running = true
                }
            }
        }
        Timer {
            id: in_timer
            interval: table.duration; repeat: true; running: false
            
            
            function hitsRightRacket() {
                if ((ball.x + ball.width >= redRacket.x &&
                     ball.x <= redRacket.x + redRacket.width) &&
                        (ball.y + ball.height >= redRacket.y &&
                         ball.y <= redRacket.y + redRacket.height))
                    return true
                return false
            }
            function hitsLeftRacket() {
                if ((ball.x + ball.width >= blackRacket.x &&
                     ball.x < blackRacket.x + blackRacket.width)  &&
                        (ball.y + ball.height >= blackRacket.y &&
                         ball.y <= blackRacket.y + blackRacket.height))
                    return true
                return false
            }
            function hitsUpperOrLowerWall(){
                if (ball.y <= 0 || ball.y + ball.height >= table.height)
                    return true
                return false
            }
            function hitsRightWall() {
                if (ball.x + ball.width >= table.width)
                    return true
                else return false
            }
            function hitsLeftWall() {
                if (ball.x <= 0) return true
                else return false
            }
            
            onTriggered: {
                if (hitsRightWall()) {
                    in_timer.stop()
                    leftCounter.count++
                    out_timer.interval = 2000
                    out_timer.running = true
                }
                else if (hitsLeftWall()) {
                    in_timer.stop()
                    rightCounter.count++
                    out_timer.interval = 2000
                    out_timer.running = true
                }
                else if (hitsRightRacket()) {
                    if (redRacket.yUwards) {
                        if (ball.yincrement == 0)
                            ball.yincrement = -ball.ran
                        else if (ball.yincrement > 0)
                            ball.yincrement *= -1
                        interval = (table.duration/4)
                    }
                    else if (redRacket.yDwards) {
                        if (ball.yincrement == 0)
                            ball.yincrement = ball.ran
                        else if (ball.yincrement < 0)
                            ball.yincrement *= -1
                        interval = (table.duration/4)
                    }
                    else {
                        ball.yincrement = 0
                        interval = (table.duration/2)
                    }
                    ball.xincrement *= -1
                    running = false
                    right_return_timer.running = true
                }
                else if (hitsLeftRacket()) {
                    if(blackRacket.yUwards) {
                        if (ball.yincrement == 0)
                            ball.yincrement = -ball.ran
                        else if (ball.yincrement > 0)
                            ball.yincrement *= -1
                        interval = (table.duration/4)
                    }
                    else if (blackRacket.yDwards) {
                        if (ball.yincrement == 0)
                            ball.yincrement = ball.ran
                        else if (ball.yincrement < 0)
                            ball.yincrement *= -1
                        interval = (table.duration/4)
                    }
                    else {
                        ball.yincrement = 0
                        interval = (table.duration/2)
                    }
                    ball.xincrement *= -1
                    running = false
                    left_return_timer.running = true
                }
                else if (hitsUpperOrLowerWall())
                    ball.yincrement *= -1
                
                // Move Ball
                ball.x = ball.x + (ball.xincrement * table.step);
                ball.y = ball.y + (ball.yincrement * table.step);
                
                if(rightCounter.count + leftCounter.count == 21) {
                    in_timer.stop()
                    if (rightCounter.count > leftCounter.count)
                        rightWin.visible = true
                    else
                        leftWin.visible = true
                }
            }
        }
    }
}

[J.Hilk]

Hi @tomy , sorry for the late response.

I had a lengthly break, sickness and holiday - thankfully not overlapping. But I'm back now and will take a look later today. I actually managed not to touch my laptop during that time, that was difficult I'll tell ya.

Any progress in the last 23 days ?

Greetings.

[tomy]

@J.Hilk
Hi J.Hilk, welcome back. :)
I'm very glad that your sickness and holiday haven't had overlapping. :)
I hope you're very well now. And Happy New Year to you. :)

I see and it's OK. I'm appreciative for your assistance. :) Thanks.
Welcome back once again.

Any progress in the last 23 days ?

That last version was actually modified many times. :) That is, each time I modified it and edited the code here in that last version making it the most recent one for you when you'll get back.

The problem was that and I found no remedy so I thought of using a ParallelAnimation as the tool for moving the ball hoping it resolves the issue with the effect of moving the rackets on the ball's movement.

I'm still working on it and today or tomorrow will test this new version and post it here too. Can it be a good solution to the problem in your point of view please?

[tomy]

Well, to cope with that problem I tried Animations in the code the way below.
Other components are as before and here is the code after the stopGame() function in main.qml:

...
ParallelAnimation {
           id: anim
           NumberAnimation {
               target: ball
               properties: "x"
               to: in_timer.xMove
           }
           NumberAnimation {
               target: ball
               properties: "y"
               to: in_timer.yMove
           }
       }
       
       Timer {
           interval: 40; repeat: true; running: true
           
           onTriggered: {
               redRacket.yUwards = false
               redRacket.yDwards = false
               blackRacket.yUwards = false
               blackRacket.yDwards = false
           }
       }
       Timer {
           id: out_timer
           interval: 1; repeat: false; running: false
           
           function lightChange() {
               if (table.lightState) {
                   rightLight.color = "silver"
                   leftLight.color= "lime"
               }
               else {
                   rightLight.color = "lime"
                   leftLight.color= "silver"
               }
               table.lightState = !table.lightState
           }
           
           onTriggered: {
               ball.xincrement = Math.random() + 0.5
               ball.yincrement = Math.random() + 0.5
               
               if (table.count % 5 == 0) {
                   table.turn = !table.turn
                   lightChange()
               }
               
               if (table.turn)
                   ball.xincrement *= -1
               
               ball.x = table.width/2
               ball.y = table.height/2
               
               if (ball.yincrement > 1.1)
                   ball.yincrement *= -1
               
               in_timer.restart()
               table.count++
           }
       }
       Timer {
           id: right_return_timer
           interval: 1; repeat: true; running: false
           onTriggered: {
               in_timer.xMove += ball.xincrement * table.step
               in_timer.yMove += ball.yincrement * table.step
               anim.restart()
               if(ball.x + ball.width < redRacket.x) {
                   running = false
                   in_timer.running = true
               }
           }
       }
       Timer {
           id: left_return_timer
           interval: 1; repeat: true; running: false
           onTriggered: {
               in_timer.xMove += ball.xincrement * table.step
               in_timer.yMove += ball.yincrement * table.step
               anim.restart()
               if(ball.x > blackRacket.x + blackRacket.width) {
                   running = false
                   in_timer.running = true
               }
           }
       }
       Timer {
           id: in_timer
           interval: table.duration; repeat: true; running: false
           property double xMove: ball.x
           property double yMove: ball.y
           
           function hitsRightRacket() {
               if ((ball.x + ball.width >= redRacket.x &&
                    ball.x <= redRacket.x + redRacket.width) &&
                       (ball.y + ball.height >= redRacket.y &&
                        ball.y <= redRacket.y + redRacket.height))
                   return true
               return false
           }
           function hitsLeftRacket() {
               if ((ball.x + ball.width >= blackRacket.x &&
                    ball.x < blackRacket.x + blackRacket.width)  &&
                       (ball.y + ball.height >= blackRacket.y &&
                        ball.y <= blackRacket.y + blackRacket.height))
                   return true
               return false
           }
           function hitsUpperOrLowerWall(){
               if (ball.y <= 0)
                   return true
               else if (ball.y + ball.height >= table.height)
                   return true
               return false
           }
           function hitsRightWall() {
               if (ball.x + ball.width >= table.width)
                   return true
               return false
           }
           function hitsLeftWall() {
               if (ball.x <= 0) return true
               else return false
           }
           
           onTriggered: {
               if (hitsRightWall()) {
                   stop()
                   leftCounter.count++
                   out_timer.interval = 2000
                   out_timer.running = true
               }
               else if (hitsLeftWall()) {
                   stop()
                   rightCounter.count++
                   out_timer.interval = 2000
                   out_timer.running = true
               }
               else if (hitsRightRacket()) {
                   if (redRacket.yUwards) {
                       if (ball.yincrement == 0)
                           ball.yincrement = -ball.ran
                       else if (ball.yincrement > 0)
                           ball.yincrement = ball.yincrement > 0 ?
                                       -ball.yincrement: ball.yincrement
                       interval = (table.duration/4)
                   }
                   else if (redRacket.yDwards) {
                       if (ball.yincrement == 0)
                           ball.yincrement = ball.ran
                       else if (ball.yincrement < 0)
                           ball.yincrement = ball.yincrement > 0 ?
                                       -ball.yincrement: ball.yincrement
                       interval = (table.duration/4)
                   }
                   else {
                       ball.yincrement = 0
                       interval = (table.duration/2)
                   }
                   ball.xincrement = ball.xincrement > 0 ?
                               -ball.xincrement: ball.xincrement
                   running = false
                   right_return_timer.running = true
               }
               else if (hitsLeftRacket()) {
                   if(blackRacket.yUwards) {
                       if (ball.yincrement == 0)
                           ball.yincrement = -ball.ran
                       else if (ball.yincrement > 0)
                           ball.yincrement = ball.yincrement > 0 ?
                                       -ball.yincrement: ball.yincrement
                       interval = (table.duration/4)
                   }
                   else if (blackRacket.yDwards) {
                       if (ball.yincrement == 0)
                           ball.yincrement = ball.ran
                       else if (ball.yincrement < 0)
                           ball.yincrement = ball.yincrement > 0 ?
                                       -ball.yincrement: ball.yincrement
                       interval = (table.duration/4)
                   }
                   else {
                       ball.yincrement = 0
                       interval = (table.duration/2)
                   }
                   ball.xincrement = ball.xincrement > 0 ?
                               -ball.xincrement: ball.xincrement
                   running = false
                   left_return_timer.running = true
               }
               else if (hitsUpperOrLowerWall())
                   ball.yincrement = ball.yincrement > 0 ?
                               -ball.yincrement: ball.yincrement
               
               // Move Ball
               xMove += (ball.xincrement * table.step);
               yMove += (ball.yincrement * table.step);
               anim.restart()
               
               if(rightCounter.count + leftCounter.count == 21) {
                   stop()
                   if (rightCounter.count > leftCounter.count)
                       rightWin.visible = true
                   else
                       leftWin.visible = true
               }
           }
       }
   }
}

This code also has several problems! One of them is that the ball doesn't stop when it hits the right or left wall. I tired several statements, like:
stop()
in_timer.stop()
running = false
anim.stop()
but neither works!

[J.Hilk]

hey @tomy ,

I used the code from your previous post, the one before the last one, and brought it on my iphone.

For me it works flawlessly, no slowdown at all.

Take a look at this video:
Video
Edit: video link fixed, thanks to @mrjj

In fact, the animation/movement of the ball is too fast in my opinion.

Did you compile the release version for your android device? Debug versions are ressource demanding and may result in slow animations on old devices.

The racket movment invokes a property binding recalculations, that is executed as soon as the event loop returns, I believe.
The Movement of the ball and checks are all depending on timers, during the property binding induced calculations those timers may queue up, that then results in a slow Ball-Animation.

[mrjj]

Hi
Video link didnt work for me but i could extract
https://vimeo.com/251451461

[tomy]

@J.Hilk

For me it works flawlessly, no slowdown at all.
Take a look at this video:
Video
Edit: video link fixed, thanks to @mrjj

Hallo, Thank you very much.

In fact, the animation/movement of the ball is too fast in my opinion.

I think by increasing table.duration it will be solved

Did you compile the release version for your android device? Debug versions are ressource demanding and may result in slow animations on old devices.

Well, when testing on the Desktop kit on my Windows, the program has no problem. It's fine. When switching to "Android for armeabi-v7a (GCC 4.9, Qt 5.10.0 for Android armv7)" kit in both Debug and Release modes, I get these two issues in the Issues window which are the same apparently. I don't know if it's related to the problem on Android devices or not.

:-1: warning: "D:\android-ndk-r10e\toolchains\arm-linux-androideabi-4.9\prebuilt\windows-x86_64\bin\arm-linux-androideabi-gcc" is used by qmake, but "D:\android-ndk-r10e\toolchains\arm-linux-androideabi-4.9\prebuilt\windows-x86_64\bin\arm-linux-androideabi-gcc.exe" is configured in the kit.
Please update your kit or choose a mkspec for qmake that matches your target environment better.

:-1: warning: "D:\android-ndk-r10e\toolchains\arm-linux-androideabi-4.9\prebuilt\windows-x86_64\bin\arm-linux-androideabi-g++" is used by qmake, but "D:\android-ndk-r10e\toolchains\arm-linux-androideabi-4.9\prebuilt\windows-x86_64\bin\arm-linux-androideabi-g++.exe" is configured in the kit.
Please update your kit or choose a mkspec for qmake that matches your target environment better.

The racket movment invokes a property binding recalculations, that is executed as soon as the event loop returns, I believe.
The Movement of the ball and checks are all depending on timers, during the property binding induced calculations those timers may queue up, that then results in a slow Ball-Animation.

I'm not sure I can understand it well. Probably it's a too advanced for me. If it can be a lead, is there any solution for that please?

[J.Hilk]

@tomy mmh, my Idea would be to marry your QMl-program with a cpp class, that does the heavy stuff.

Your cpp-class could/should have Q_properties that are bound to ball.x and ball.y and right/leftracket position.

That class could emit signals when the ball hits something and trigger the new ball position etc.

Thats a bit more work than I can justify right now, but I'll look into it a bit more during lunch-break ;-)

[tomy]

@J.Hilk
Hi, thank you for your suggestion. I've used C++ for console applications on Visual Studio and also used it on Qt Creator for a few Qt programs. And also have used QML on Qt Creator as in this program. But I've never used C++ in a QML program! So it seems hard for me. But if it's the solution to make the program run correctly on Android devices, OK, I will go for that. But where to start?

[J.Hilk]

@tomy

theres a very basic example in the docu, that is really good to get general understanding of a c++ backend for a qml program:

Let me link that for you

[J.Hilk]

heres an quick example how your Backend could look like:

//PropertyBase.h
#ifndef PROPERTYBASE_H
#define PROPERTYBASE_H

#include <QObject>

class PropertyBase : public QObject
{
    Q_OBJECT
    
    Q_PROPERTY(double xBall READ xBall WRITE setXBall NOTIFY xBallChanged)
    Q_PROPERTY(double yBall READ yBall WRITE setYBall NOTIFY yBallChanged)
    Q_PROPERTY(double wBall READ wBall WRITE setWBall NOTIFY wBallChanged)
    Q_PROPERTY(double hBall READ hBall WRITE setHBall NOTIFY hBallChanged)
    
    Q_PROPERTY(double xRedRacket READ xRedRacket WRITE setXRedRacket NOTIFY xRedRacketChanged)
    Q_PROPERTY(double yRedRacket READ yRedRacket WRITE setYRedRacket NOTIFY yRedRacketChanged)
    Q_PROPERTY(double wRedRacket READ wRedRacket WRITE setWRedRacket NOTIFY wRedRacketChanged)
    Q_PROPERTY(double hRedRacket READ hRedRacket WRITE setHRedRacket NOTIFY hRedRacketChanged)
    
    Q_PROPERTY(double xBlackRacket READ xBlackRacket WRITE setXBlackRacket NOTIFY xBlackRacketChanged)
    Q_PROPERTY(double yBlackRacket READ yBlackRacket WRITE setYBlackRacket NOTIFY yBlackRacketChanged)
    Q_PROPERTY(double wBlackRacket READ wBlackRacket WRITE setWBlackRacket NOTIFY wBlackRacketChanged)
    Q_PROPERTY(double hBlackRacket READ hBlackRacket WRITE setHBlackRacket NOTIFY hBlackRacketChanged)
    
    Q_PROPERTY(double wScreen READ wScreen WRITE setWScreen NOTIFY wScreenChanged)
    Q_PROPERTY(double hScreen READ hScreen WRITE setHScreen NOTIFY hScreenChanged)
    
    inline double xBall(){return m_xBall;}
    inline double yBall(){return m_yBall;}
    inline double wBall(){return m_wBall;}
    inline double hBall(){return m_hBall;}
    
    inline double xRedRacket(){return m_xrRacket;}
    inline double yRedRacket(){return m_yrRacket;}
    inline double wRedRacket(){return m_wrRacket;}
    inline double hRedRacket(){return m_hrRacket;}
    
    inline double xBlackRacket(){return m_xbRacket;}
    inline double yBlackRacket(){return m_ybRacket;}
    inline double wBlackRacket(){return m_wbRacket;}
    inline double hBlackRacket(){return m_hbRacket;}
    
    inline double wScreen(){return m_wScreen;}
    inline double hScreen(){return m_hScreen;}
    
    void setXBall(const double &);
    void setYBall(const double &);
    void setWBall(const double &);
    void setHBall(const double &);
    
    void setXRedRacket(const double &);
    void setYRedRacket(const double &);
    void setWRedRacket(const double &);
    void setHRedRacket(const double &);
    
    void setXBlackRacket(const double &);
    void setYBlackRacket(const double &);
    void setWBlackRacket(const double &);
    void setHBlackRacket(const double &);
    
    void setWScreen(const double &);
    void setHScreen(const double &);
public:
    explicit PropertyBase(QObject *parent = nullptr);

signals:
    void xBallChanged();
    void yBallChanged();
    void wBallChanged();
    void hBallChanged();
    
    void xRedRacketChanged();
    void yRedRacketChanged();
    void wRedRacketChanged();
    void hRedRacketChanged();
    
    void xBlackRacketChanged();
    void yBlackRacketChanged();
    void wBlackRacketChanged();
    void hBlackRacketChanged();
    
    void wScreenChanged();
    void hScreenChanged();
protected:
    double m_xBall;
    double m_yBall;
    double m_wBall;
    double m_hBall;
    
    double m_xrRacket;
    double m_yrRacket;
    double m_wrRacket;
    double m_hrRacket;
    
    double m_xbRacket;
    double m_ybRacket;
    double m_wbRacket;
    double m_hbRacket;
    
    double m_wScreen;
    double m_hScreen;
};

#endif // PROPERTYBASE_H

//

//PropertyBase.cpp
#include "propertybase.h"


PropertyBase::PropertyBase(QObject *parent) : QObject(parent)
{

}

void PropertyBase::setXBall(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_xBall){
        m_xBall = value;
        emit xBallChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setYBall(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_YBall){
        m_yBall = value;
        emit yBallChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setWBall(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_wBall){
        m_wBall = value;
        emit wBallChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setHBall(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_hBall){
        m_hBall = value;
        emit hBallChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setXRedRacket(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_xrRacket){
        m_xrRacket = value;
        emit xRedRacketChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setYRedRacket(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_yrRacket){
        m_yrRacket = value;
        emit yRedRacketChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setWRedRacket(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_wrRacket){
        m_wrRacket = value;
        emit wRedRacketChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setHRedRacket(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_hrRacket){
        m_hrRacket = value;
        emit hRedRacketChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setXBlackRacket(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_xbRacket){
        m_xbRacket = value;
        emit xBlackRacketChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setYBlackRacket(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_ybRacket){
        m_ybRacket = value;
        emit yBlackRacketChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setWBlackRacket(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_wbRacket){
        m_wbRacket = value;
        emit wBlackRacketChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setHBlackRacket(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_hbRacket){
        m_hbRacket = value;
        emit hBlackRacketChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setWScreen(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_wScreen){
        m_wScreen = value;
        emit wScreenChanged();
    }
}

void PropertyBase::setHScreen(const double &value)
{
    if(value != m_hScreen){
        m_hScreen = value;
        emit hScreenChanged();
    }
}

//Backend.h
#ifndef BACKEND_H
#define BACKEND_H

#include "propertybase.h"
#include <QTimer>

class BackEnd : public PropertyBase
{
    Q_OBJECT
    
public:
    explicit BackEnd(PropertyBase *parent = nullptr);

    Q_INVOKABLE void timerStart(){m_BallTimer.start(m_timerInterval);}
    Q_INVOKABLE void timerStop(){m_BallTimer.stop();}
    
    Q_INVOKABLE void setInterval(int & interval){
        m_timerInterval = interval;
        m_BallTimer.setInterval(interval);
    }
    
signals:
    void rightWallhit();
    void leftWallHit();
    void rightRacketHit();
    void leftRacketHit();
    void upperOrLowerWallHit();
    
    void moveBall();

public slots:
    
private:
    bool hitsRightRacket();
    bool hitsLeftRacket();
    
    bool hitsUpperOrLowerWall();
    bool hitsRightWall();
    bool hitsLeftWall();
    
private slots:
    void doCalculation();
    
protected:
    int m_timerInterval = 10;
    QTimer m_BallTimer;
};

#endif // BACKEND_H

//Backend.cpp
#include "backend.h"

BackEnd::BackEnd(PropertyBase *parent) : PropertyBase(parent)
{
    connect(&m_BallTimer, &QTimer::timeout, this, &BackEnd::doCalculation);
}

bool BackEnd::hitsRightRacket()
{
    if( (xBall() + wBall() >= xRedRacket() && xBall() <= xRedRacket() + wRedRacket() ) &&
        (yBall() + hBall() >= yRedRacket() && yBall() <= yRedRacket() + hRedRacket() ))
        return true;
    
    return false;
}

bool BackEnd::hitsLeftRacket()
{
    if( (xBall() + wBall() >= xBlackRacket() && xBall() <= xBlackRacket() + wBlackRacket() ) &&
        (yBall() + hBall() >= yBlackRacket() && yBall() <= yBlackRacket() + hBlackRacket() ))
        return true;
    
    return false;
}

bool BackEnd::hitsUpperOrLowerWall()
{
    if(yBall() <= 0 || yBall() +hBall() >= hScreen())
        return true;
    
    return false;
}

bool BackEnd::hitsRightWall()
{
    if(xBall() + wBall() >= wScreen())
        return true;
    
    return false;
}

bool BackEnd::hitsLeftWall()
{
    if(xBall() <= 0)
        return true;
    
    return false;
}

void BackEnd::doCalculation()
{
    if(hitsRightWall()){
        timerStop();
        emit rightWallhit();
    }
    
    if(hitsLeftWall()){
        timerStop();
        emit leftWallHit();
    }
    
    if(hitsRightRacket())
        emit rightRacketHit();
    
    if(hitsLeftRacket())
        emit leftRacketHit();
    
    if(hitsUpperOrLowerWall())
        emit upperOrLowerWallHit();
    
    emit moveBall();
}

//main.cpp
#include <QGuiApplication>
#include <QQmlApplicationEngine>

#include "backend.h"

int main(int argc, char *argv[])
{
    QGuiApplication app(argc, argv);
    
    qmlRegisterType<BackEnd>("myBackend",1,0,"BackEnd");

    QQmlApplicationEngine engine;
    engine.load(QUrl(QStringLiteral("qrc:/main.qml")));
    if (engine.rootObjects().isEmpty())
        return -1;

    return app.exec();
}

//main.qml
Window {
    id: window
    visibility: Window.Maximized
    title: qsTr("The PingPong Game - A QML Game")
    color: "gray"
    
    
    BackEnd{
        id:myBackend
        
        xBall: ball.x
        yBall: ball.y
        wBall: ball.width
        hBall: ball.height
        
        xRedRacket: redRacket.x
        yRedRacket: redRacket.y
        //....
        
        onRightWallhit: {
            leftCounter.count++
            out_timer.interval = 2000
            out_timer.running = true
        }
        onLeftWallHit: {
            rightCounter.count++
            out_timer.interval = 2000
            out_timer.running = true
        }
        onRightRacketHit: {
            if (redRacket.yUwards) {
                if (ball.yincrement == 0)
                    ball.yincrement = -ball.ran
                else if (ball.yincrement > 0)
                    ball.yincrement *= -1
                
            }
            else if (redRacket.yDwards) {
                if (ball.yincrement == 0)
                    ball.yincrement = ball.ran
                else if (ball.yincrement < 0)
                    ball.yincrement *= -1
                setInterval(table.duration/4)
            }
        }
         ....
    }
.....
}

[tomy]

@J.Hilk
Thank you many times. :-)
I must analyse the code for both being familiar with the code and also the way C++ and QML have been mixed. :-)

[J.Hilk]

@tomy
great,

but keep in mind, its just an example.
When I wrote it down, I realized quickly, that I would move a lot more into the c++ class.

You could(should) do the new Ball-Position calculation also in the backend.

you can set the Balls position through the QProperty-binding

xBall: ball.x
yBall: ball.y

via calling setXBall() and setYBall inside the cpp-class.
In the end there should than be no need for any QML-side timers.

That should clean up and speed up your QML part significantly.