How do I connect via COM port?

IAIPDS

That's what I thought, but since I've only been working with manufactured drivers I haven't been seeing if something underlying like that has been happening.

Still, to me it doesn't make sense that this would be the case, because as I'm writing a "driver" for the third party app, I have to return whatever values on my own. Right now I have the connection function returning no error, and I'm setting the app's "connected" option to true. Seems like that should be sufficient, no? Unless I'm screwing up something with Qt, I thought.

SGaist

Hi and welcome to devnet,

One thing you don't check: if the open call was successful.

? Offline

Ah, I think I misunderstood how your setup looks like; I thought said third party application was running on the microcontroller board and that you were writing a PC program that tries to communicate with the 3rd party application.

IAIPDS

Sort of inverted actually, I'm writing a program for the microcontroller board and writing a driver to interface it with a PC program. The driver I'm using is sort of from a template.

And it's true that I'm not checking to see if it's open, but I'm also fairly confident it's not opening.

I don't have much/any experience with COM ports but is it possible that for some reason the COM port itself is being "blocked"? Like only one program can access the port at a time, essentially?

hskoglund

Hi, I've also struggled with COM ports (connecting a PC to cigarette vending machines :-) and to see what's going on in the COM port, I use PortMon
Run it before starting your Qt app, and it will show everything that happens with your COM port.
(Note: Last time I tested I couldn't get PortMon to run in Windows 10, but Windows 7 works fine.)

Edit: forgot to answer you question: yes, it's true that only one program at the time can use a specific COM port, so you have to check that open() worked. (PortMon uses some low-level tricks to open it anyway, but that's another story.)

IAIPDS

I'm taking a look at PortMon now! Thanks.
Although, I do wonder if it will work - since it's a driver for an application and not an application itself, I actually can't even really test my code except via the third party app itself. And at that point, the program is already in DLL form. That said, if PortMon is supposed to show port requests - and assuming there are no setup steps I'm missing - it doesn't appear to be really doing anything. I didn't see anything pop up when trying to execute the connection for my program.

Any thoughts?

hskoglund

Hi, about PortMon, it doesn't show any popups, to see what's happening, you need to have PortMon's window visible, it will show the events in it, for example if a program opens that COM port, or changes the speed etc.

Edit: also in the Capture menu in PortMon, check in the Ports submenu that your COM port is captured ok, that helps :-)

IAIPDS

Hmm.. right now nothing is popping up in the window (that's what I meant by pop up, my mistake) and the window says Portmon - not connected. Is there some step I'm missing?

hskoglund

If it's not connected, perhaps you didn't start PortMon before starting your driver and app; it needs to be launched before your stuff. Also check that Capture submenu (as I said in my prev. post).

IAIPDS

Ah, didn't refresh my site to see that edit - well, the Ports submenu is grayed out and I tried closing and reopening the apps in the proper order and still nothing...

hskoglund

Hnmm, perhaps this StackOverflow post can help (look at the answer at the bottom)

IAIPDS

That method's throwing a file not found error... haha I can't even work the thing that's supposed to work the thing I can't work

hskoglund

It's called yak shaving :-)

COM ports are indeed finicky to debug. In the old days I used a hardware dongle with LEDs and RS232 male/female connectors as a "hardware" debugger, when the LEDS flashed you'd know something was afoot.

Another alternative is to use ol' HyperTerminal if you have Windows XP somewhere it's included.

IAIPDS

Yeah I tried opening Portmon and then just moving the program into my arduino to see if the activity popped up in the feed but nothing happened, though the program loaded successfully (although that was never a problem). I'm also not using XP, unfortunately. Seems that port checking may not be the way to go for this troubleshooting?

hskoglund

Yeah sorry PortMon may well have past its prime. You could try connecting the cable to another PC instead of the Arduino board, and on that other PC run Qt's chat demo program or something similar.

Also another trick I remember, take a paperclip and connect/shortcircuit pins 2 and 3 with each other, easiest on the male RS232-connector. When you connect the Tx and Rx pins that way, it means everything you transmit comes back directly (echo). Sometimes that can be a helpful diagnostic, just to see if anything arrives...