Upload large files HTTP request, without increasing the application memory.

Tusharh

My program needs to upload huge files of 1GB,2GB,etc . I have tried using QHttpMultipart request & other PUT & POST requests on QNetworkAccessManager. Every time a QNetworkRequest is build, the application memory shoots up from 20MB to 1GB or 2GB as per the file, which leads to my application crashing (WINDOWS QT APP).

QHttpMultiPart *multiPart = new QHttpMultiPart(QHttpMultiPart::FormDataType);

QHttpPart textPart;
textPart.setHeader(QNetworkRequest::ContentDispositionHeader, QVariant("form-data; name=\"text\""));
textPart.setBody("my text");

QHttpPart imagePart;
imagePart.setHeader(QNetworkRequest::ContentTypeHeader, QVariant("image/jpeg"));
imagePart.setHeader(QNetworkRequest::ContentDispositionHeader, QVariant("form-data; name=\"image\""));
QFile *file = new QFile("LargeFile.zip");
file->open(QIODevice::ReadOnly);
imagePart.setBodyDevice(file); 
file->setParent(multiPart); 

multiPart->append(textPart);
multiPart->append(imagePart);

QUrl url("http://my.server.tld");
QNetworkRequest request(url);

QNetworkAccessManager manager;
QNetworkReply *reply = manager.post(request, multiPart);
multiPart->setParent(reply); 

**HUGE increase in application memory equivalent to the file size at this point after POST request is fired,as whole file is read & added into request body**

What I found in C# is that, it's possible to upload huge files without increasing or reading the whole file. They keep on writing on the http request stream in chunks.

In this code whatever may the File size be in GBs, application memory never goes beyond 40MB.

public void upload(string url, string imagename, string imagepath, string finalType)
{
	FileStream fileStream = null;
	Stream rs = null;
	WebResponse lobjResponse = null;
	string lstrResponse = string.Empty;
	bool lblnIsConnected = true;
	long mlngBytesUploaded = 0;
	long llngContentLength = 0;
	long[] llngarrProgressStatusData = new long[2];
	string pstrResponse = string.Empty;

	try
	{
		long lintContentLenght = 0;
		string boundary = "---------------------------" + DateTime.Now.Ticks.ToString("x");
		byte[] boundarybytes = System.Text.Encoding.ASCII.GetBytes("\r\n--" + boundary + "\r\n");

		string formdataTemplate = "Content-Disposition: form-data; name=\"{0}\"\r\n\r\n{1}";
		string formitem = string.Format(formdataTemplate, "abc", "abc-val");
		byte[] formitembytes = System.Text.Encoding.UTF8.GetBytes(formitem);

		string headerTemplate = "Content-Disposition: form-data; name=\"{0}\"; filename=\"{1}\"\r\nContent-Type: {2}\r\n\r\n";
		string header = string.Format(headerTemplate, imagename, imagename, finalType);
		byte[] headerbytes = System.Text.Encoding.UTF8.GetBytes(header);

		byte[] trailer = System.Text.Encoding.ASCII.GetBytes("\r\n--" + boundary + "--\r\n");

		fileStream = new FileStream(imagepath, FileMode.Open, FileAccess.Read);

		lintContentLenght += boundarybytes.Length;
		lintContentLenght += formitembytes.Length;
		lintContentLenght += boundarybytes.Length;
		lintContentLenght += headerbytes.Length;
		lintContentLenght += fileStream.Length;
		lintContentLenght += trailer.Length;
		
		wr = (HttpWebRequest)WebRequest.Create(url);
		wr.AllowWriteStreamBuffering = false;
		wr.ContentType = "multipart/form-data; boundary=" + boundary;
		wr.ContentLength = lintContentLenght;
		wr.Method = "POST";
		wr.KeepAlive = true;
		
		  using (rs = wr.GetRequestStream())
		  {
			  rs.Write(boundarybytes, 0, boundarybytes.Length);
			  rs.Write(formitembytes, 0, formitembytes.Length);
			  rs.Write(boundarybytes, 0, boundarybytes.Length);
			  rs.Write(headerbytes, 0, headerbytes.Length);

			  int bytesRead = 0;
			  byte[] bufferSize = new byte[4096];

			  llngContentLength = wr.ContentLength;
			  llngarrProgressStatusData[0] = llngContentLength;

                          // BECAUSE OF READING FILE DATA in chunks & WRITING IT to the STREAM. HERE WHOLE FILE ISN'T READ & SET INTO REQUEST like in QHTTPMULTIPART request. Application memory remains constant in C# code.** 
			  while ((bytesRead = fileStream.Read(bufferSize, 0, bufferSize.Length)) != 0) 
			  {

				  if (!lblnIsConnected) break;
					mlngBytesUploaded += bytesRead;
				  rs.Write(bufferSize, 0, bytesRead);
				  
				  if (mlngBytesUploaded > llngContentLength)
					  mlngBytesUploaded = llngContentLength;
					  
				  llngarrProgressStatusData[1] = mlngBytesUploaded;
				  NotifyHTTPProgressBarUpdate(mlngBytesUploaded, llngContentLength);
			  }

			  fileStream.Close();

			  if (lblnIsConnected)
			  {
				  rs.Write(trailer, 0, trailer.Length);
				  rs.Close();
			  }
		  }
	}
}

Sending file chunks is an option but currently I don't have that support on my server.

Can you please suggest me a similar way of implementing above C# code in QT to upload file in a stream over HTTP PUT/POST request on a given URL.

Thanks in advance!

sierdzio

QNAM accepts a QIODevice in post() and put() - link.

So when you pass a QFile instance to that method, it works using streaming operators (without loading the whole file into RAM). Have you tried that approach?

raven-worx

@sierdzio said in Upload large files HTTP request, without increasing the application memory.:

it work using streaming operators (without loading the whole file into RAM)

that's what i personally would also expect using the above code. But the docs are not clear regarding this.

sierdzio

@raven-worx said in Upload large files HTTP request, without increasing the application memory.:

@sierdzio said in Upload large files HTTP request, without increasing the application memory.:

it work using streaming operators (without loading the whole file into RAM)

that's what i personally would also expect using the above code. But the docs are not clear regarding this.

I think this line is quite clear:

because the content is not copied when using this method, but read directly from the device

Anyway, I did not link to QHttpPart, I linked to QNAM directly. Both approaches seem likely to be good.

Tusharh

@sierdzio I tried passing QFile instance to POST & PUT methods of QNetworkAcessManager. No success. Whole file is loaded into memory.

sierdzio

@Tusharh said in Upload large files HTTP request, without increasing the application memory.:

@sierdzio I tried passing QFile instance to POST & PUT methods of QNetworkAcessManager. No success. Whole file is loaded into memory.

OK, I believe it is a bug, then, please report it.

Tusharh

@sierdzio I'm using QT 5.4.1. My application has some dependency on 5.4.1. How can I know if this bug is resolved in 5.7(besides installing QT 5.7 on my machine)?

raven-worx

@Tusharh
Is this the whole code you are using? Because even when only one part of the whole multi-part object is sequential the whole multi-part would be sequential and thus loaded into memory.

Tusharh

@raven-worx Yes, this is the code. I also did separate new code QNAM()->PUT(request,QFile*) & QNAM()->POST(request,QFile*) on my QT 5.4.1 setup. Everytime after executing the request application memory goes on increasing till it is equivalent to given file size(here I used 1GB file & memory increased by 1GB).

Unsolved Upload large files HTTP request, without increasing the application memory.