How do I read in a text file line by line that uses Hex0D as a line terminator?
-
[quote author="Franzk" date="1299695807"][quote author="peppe" date="1299694316"][quote author="Franzk" date="1299693469"]Actually, the root of the problem is that Qt doesn't accept \r as a valid EOL.[/quote]
Why should it? No platform supported by Qt uses that control character. [/quote]Mac is no longer supported?
Even if it is true, \r is still a valid line ending and should therefore be supported, even if only by configuration.[/quote]
Therefore I'm allowed to argue that ASCII 0x07 (BEL) is a valid line ending in my wonderful system, therefore QTextStream should support it? :)
Come on, stick to reality: if you need custom line endings handle the line splitting yourself. It's easy and always works.
(BTW: where do those files come from? Mac OS 9?)
Eventually, you can suggest an API extension to allow for custom line endings in QTextStream, and/or provide the implementation yourself (quite easy) and submit a merge request.
-
[quote author="Franzk" date="1299695807"][quote author="peppe" date="1299694316"][quote author="Franzk" date="1299693469"]Actually, the root of the problem is that Qt doesn't accept \r as a valid EOL.[/quote]
Why should it? No platform supported by Qt uses that control character. [/quote]Mac is no longer supported?
Even if it is true, \r is still a valid line ending and should therefore be supported, even if only by configuration.[/quote]
Mac OS 9 was never supported during Qt 3 nor Qt 4. Mac OS X uses Unix newlines ('\n').
-
[quote author="peppe" date="1299701793"]
[quote author="Jonathan" date="1299701652"]My code would have been much tidier if I could have specified the end of line character.But to be general, it would have to be a string. Didn't some systems use "x0Ax0D"?
[/quote]Yes, f.i. Windows.[/quote]
That has always been \r\n, not \n\r as stated above.
-
[quote author="peppe" date="1299701466"]Therefore I'm allowed to argue that ASCII 0x07 (BEL) is a valid line ending in my wonderful system, therefore QTextStream should support it? :)[/quote]That might be taking it a bit far, but if you insist, I'm sure the implementer could take into account that you wish to view BEL as a EOL as well ;).
Edit: I just added a note to the issue referencing "the unicode standard on newlines":http://www.unicode.org/standard/reports/tr13/tr13-5.html.
-
Hi Franzk,
thank you for your note, but the Newline character I even known is NL, not NEL, or this is another definition that I don't know?
Qt full respect the Unicode specifications for this character? Because regardless from this specific case, the differences between the line termination in files became very important on Qt development environment that can work on different desktop platforms (Linux+Mac and Windows) where the sources the same are saved with different line-termination characters: if you try to open a source code created with QT-Linux under Windows (with notepad) it result unreadable, while Qt-Windows does the right interpretation.
-
[quote author="Franzk" date="1299736994"][quote author="peppe" date="1299701793"]
[quote author="Jonathan" date="1299701652"]My code would have been much tidier if I could have specified the end of line character.But to be general, it would have to be a string. Didn't some systems use "x0Ax0D"?
[/quote]Yes, f.i. Windows.[/quote]
That has always been \r\n, not \n\r as stated above.[/quote]
Oops, you're right :-) I switched the bytes in my mind.
