QNetworkAccessManager HTTP(S) upload failure
-
I'm trying to upload some files to a web service proxied by nginx. This works flawlessly as long as the file size is relatively small (i.e. < 64k). When sending larger files, the remote server simply closes the connection. This happens for both, PUT and POST methods. Qt version is 5.15.2.
Uploading the same files using cURL is O.K. However, I noticed that cURL uses the HTTP 'Expect: 100-continue' mechanism to defer the content transmission. Could that be the reason? It looks like QNetworkAccessManager doesn't do that. -
I'm trying to upload some files to a web service proxied by nginx. This works flawlessly as long as the file size is relatively small (i.e. < 64k). When sending larger files, the remote server simply closes the connection. This happens for both, PUT and POST methods. Qt version is 5.15.2.
Uploading the same files using cURL is O.K. However, I noticed that cURL uses the HTTP 'Expect: 100-continue' mechanism to defer the content transmission. Could that be the reason? It looks like QNetworkAccessManager doesn't do that.@warped-rudi
Please post your code. Difficult to guess in the dark.Software Engineer
The Qt Company, Oslo -
@warped-rudi
Please post your code. Difficult to guess in the dark.@Axel-Spoerl The source code is pretty much standard. However, I think I could figure out, what the problem is using WireShark:
I forgot to mention, that the service requires authentication. The parameter 'proxy_request_buffering off;' in nginx' config is present, which means that it will stream the HTTP message to the destination service as it arrives. I.e. nginx will not do any caching. The target service now replies with HTTP 401 as soon as it has received the headers of the incoming message. However, QNetworkAccessManager insists in pumping the whole message body even though it is clear at this point that the data will be discarded. The service and/or nginx do not expect more data to come in after the 401 was sent to the client and therefore close the connection.
A possible solution is to remove 'proxy_request_buffering off;' from nginx config. In this case, nginx will receive and cache the whole message before passing it on to the target service. QNetworkAccessManager now doesn't have to deal with the premature 401 response. The overhead introduced by this setting is acceptable for me.
The second solution seems to be using Qt6. A short test with 6.4.3 didn't show the problem at all.
-
@Axel-Spoerl The source code is pretty much standard. However, I think I could figure out, what the problem is using WireShark:
I forgot to mention, that the service requires authentication. The parameter 'proxy_request_buffering off;' in nginx' config is present, which means that it will stream the HTTP message to the destination service as it arrives. I.e. nginx will not do any caching. The target service now replies with HTTP 401 as soon as it has received the headers of the incoming message. However, QNetworkAccessManager insists in pumping the whole message body even though it is clear at this point that the data will be discarded. The service and/or nginx do not expect more data to come in after the 401 was sent to the client and therefore close the connection.
A possible solution is to remove 'proxy_request_buffering off;' from nginx config. In this case, nginx will receive and cache the whole message before passing it on to the target service. QNetworkAccessManager now doesn't have to deal with the premature 401 response. The overhead introduced by this setting is acceptable for me.
The second solution seems to be using Qt6. A short test with 6.4.3 didn't show the problem at all.
@warped-rudi
The only change from Qt5 to At6, that comes to my mind right away, is an internal change of the proxy authentication on MacOS. A few other things might also have changed inQNetworkAccessManager, but I don't know from the top of my head.
In any case,QNetworkAccessManagershould handle proxy buffering just as well as nginx does. And if Qt6 succeeds in doing the job, solution number 2 is probably the best way to go. -
W warped-rudi has marked this topic as solved on
