QWebSocket is not able to connect server

SteMMo

Hi all,
I'm trying to develop a simple websocket client for a Linux machine (embedded board with Debian GNU/Linux 9.3 (stretch) and Qt 5.7.1).
My code is the following (embedded in a class):

...
QObject::connect( &_ws, &QWebSocket::connected, this, &IoBoard::onConnected);
QObject::connect( &_ws, &QWebSocket::disconnected, this, &IoBoard::onDisconnected);

connect( &_ws, QOverload<QAbstractSocket::SocketError>::of(&QWebSocket::error),
    [=](QAbstractSocket::SocketError error){
        qDebug() << "[IoBoard] Error: " << error;
    }
);

QUrl url ("ws://localhost:7681");
url.setHost("10.191.40.216");
qDebug() << "[IoBoard] url: " << url.toString() << " - Scheme: " << url.scheme() << " - Host: " << url.host() << " - Port: " << url.port();
qDebug() << "[IoBoard] state:" << _ws.state();
_ws.open(url);
qDebug() << "[IoBoard] state:" << _ws.state();
...

When I run it I have:

[IoBoard] url:  "ws://10.191.40.216:7681"  - Scheme:  "ws"  - Host:  "10.191.40.216"  - Port:  7681
[IoBoard] state: QAbstractSocket::UnconnectedState
[IoBoard] state: QAbstractSocket::ConnectingState

Nothing more: 'connected' slot is never called and the server does not receive any connection.
The server is running correctly cause if I run a webpage based on Javascipt websocket I have connection.
Any clue?

PS: I overrited the address just to test the remote connection: same result.

Thanks, regards

SteMMo

Solved!

Comparing main.cpp file I found that the definition of IoBoard object was static and global (outside the main() function).
Now I defined the object inside the main() function and the connection is done.

Bonnie

Is _ws a member variable?
Try to also connect and print the destroyed signal to see if it is destroyed somewhere.

SteMMo

Yes, simply:

private:
    QWebSocket _ws;

I've connected the destroyed signal but it was recalled at the exit of the program:

[IoBoard] url:  "ws://10.191.40.216:7681"  - Scheme:  "ws"  - Host:  "10.191.40.216"  - Port:  7681
[IoBoard] state: QAbstractSocket::UnconnectedState
[IoBoard] state: QAbstractSocket::ConnectingState
...
Platform:  "xcb"
...
[IoBoard] Destroyed

Thanks

Bonnie

@SteMMo
Then it lives until exit. Looks fine.
So there is no any error signal? Even no timeout? That's weird.
Does stateChanged signal have more information?

SteMMo

@Bonnie
Added a new slot, now the debug output is:

[IoBoard] url:  "ws://localhost:7681"  - Scheme:  "ws"  - Host:  "localhost"  - Port:  7681
[IoBoard] state: QAbstractSocket::UnconnectedState
[IoBoard] StateChanged: QAbstractSocket::ConnectingState
[IoBoard] state: QAbstractSocket::ConnectingState
...
[IoBoard] Destroyed
QObject::connect: Cannot connect (null)::destroyed() to QHostInfoLookupManager::waitForThreadPoolDone()

Bonnie

@SteMMo
When you said "exit of the program", did you exit manually? Or the program just ends?
If you exit manually, how about waiting for like 10 minutes before your exit?
If your project is simple, it might also help if you post more code.

manordheim

Do you have access to the server? Does the server have anything to say?

SteMMo

@manordheim as I said in the previous message, I'm able to connect the server (it is my program running on the same machine) by a web page and websocket library via Javascript.
They communicate correctly.

SteMMo

@Bonnie I mean that I run the program, then I shut down the program by Alt-F4.
I start a 10-minutes test ...

SteMMo

@Bonnie
Right now the connection is hosted in the constructor of a global object.

/**
 * @brief IoBoard::IoBoard
 */
IoBoard::IoBoard(QObject* parent) : QObject(parent)
{
    qDebug() << "Costruttore IoBoard";

    // -- websocket

    QObject::connect( &_ws, &QWebSocket::connected, this, &IoBoard::onConnected);
    QObject::connect( &_ws, &QWebSocket::disconnected, this, &IoBoard::onDisconnected);
    QObject::connect( &_ws, &QWebSocket::destroyed, this, &IoBoard::onDestroyed);
    QObject::connect( &_ws, &QWebSocket::stateChanged, this, &IoBoard::onStateChanged);

    connect( &_ws, QOverload<QAbstractSocket::SocketError>::of(&QWebSocket::error),
        [=](QAbstractSocket::SocketError error){
            qDebug() << "[IoBoard] Errore: " << error;
        }
    );

    QUrl url ("ws://localhost:7681");
    // url.setHost("10.191.40.216");
    qDebug() << "[IoBoard] url: " << url.toString() << " - Scheme: " << url.scheme() << " - Host: " << url.host() << " - Port: " << url.port();
    qDebug() << "[IoBoard] state:" << _ws.state();
    _ws.open(url);
    qDebug() << "[IoBoard] state:" << _ws.state();
}

SteMMo

@Bonnie
More than half an hour and nothing is notified.
I also press some buttons and return but websocket does not notify anything.

Costruttore IoBoard
[IoBoard] url:  "ws://localhost:7681"  - Scheme:  "ws"  - Host:  "localhost"  - Port:  7681
[IoBoard] state: QAbstractSocket::UnconnectedState
[IoBoard] StateChanged: QAbstractSocket::ConnectingState
[IoBoard] state: QAbstractSocket::ConnectingState

Costruttore Cassetti
QSqlDatabasePrivate::addDatabase: duplicate connection name 'qt_sql_default_connection', old connection removed.
[Cassetti] open:  true
>> cassetti: 19
Costruttore Prenotazioni
Platform:  "xcb"
Farmacia:  "Locker 1 - Gruppo AC - Roman"
Cassetti:  "99"
serial:  "ttyS1"
[CheckCode] Tipo:  0  - Code: "99887766"
qml: onActFocCh
qml: OK - 123
qml: OK - 123
qml: onActFocCh
qml: onActFocCh
qml: onActFocCh
qml: onActFocCh
qml: onActFocCh
qml: onActFocCh
qml: onActFocCh

Bonnie

What's you Qt version?
Can you provide a minimal code example for others to test?

aha_1980

Hi @SteMMo,

Have you already tried the Echo Client Example and checked if that can connect to your server?

Btw, Qt 5.7.1 is quite old. Can you update to a newer version?

Regards

SteMMo

@aha_1980 Hi,
at the moment, no.
The boards on the field mount an old OS (Debian stretch); this repository provides version 5.7.1
Maybe in the future I'll be able to move on a new version (buster)

SteMMo

@aha_1980 I tried the sample and yes, it worked:

root@tinkerboard:/home/amtek/echoClient# ./echoclient -d 
WebSocket server: QUrl("ws://localhost:7681")
WebSocket connected
Message received: "Unk"

I don't understand: my code for IoBoard is basically started from the code of EchoClient class .. the code is included in a past message ..

SteMMo

Solved!

Comparing main.cpp file I found that the definition of IoBoard object was static and global (outside the main() function).
Now I defined the object inside the main() function and the connection is done.

aha_1980

Hi @SteMMo,

I'm glad you figured it out. So please mark this topic as SOLVED too.

Thanks!