Showing a mp4 in my app

MichRX7

@MichRX7 said in Showing a mp4 in my app:

error: reference to non-static member function must be called; did you mean to call it with no arguments?

Remember to include the & inside of()

I copied it right from the page, this is what I have in my code that is throwing that error:
connect(player, QOverloadQMediaPlayer::Error::of(&QMediaPlayer::error), [=](QMediaPlayer::Error error)
{
qDebug() << "Error:" << error << player->errorString;
});

JKSH

@MichRX7 said in Showing a mp4 in my app:

qDebug() << "Error:" << error << player->errorString;

Found it: errorString() needs parentheses

MichRX7

Well, there is a lot of output, not sure if you want to see all of it.

But, on the MOV file that plays correctly I see this near the end (after pressing the button to create the videowidget and play):
Thread 18 created.

~"[New Thread 0x8d0fc390 (LWP 17529)]\n"
[New Thread 0x8d0fc390 (LWP 17529)]
*running,thread-id="18"
dNOTE: INFERIOR STILL RUNNING IN STATE InferiorRunOk.

Media Status: QMediaPlayer::BufferedMedia

=thread-created,id="19",group-id="i1"
Thread 19 created.
~"[New Thread 0x8bbff390 (LWP 17530)]\n"
[New Thread 0x8bbff390 (LWP 17530)]
*running,thread-id="19"
dNOTE: INFERIOR STILL RUNNING IN STATE InferiorRunOk.

~"[Thread 0x8bbff390 (LWP 17530) exited]\n"
[Thread 0x8bbff390 (LWP 17530) exited]
=thread-exited,id="19",group-id="i1"
Thread 19 in group i1 exited.

In the MOV that won't play I see:
Thread 21 created.

~"[New Thread 0x8ddf2390 (LWP 17432)]\n"
[New Thread 0x8ddf2390 (LWP 17432)]
*running,thread-id="21"
dNOTE: INFERIOR STILL RUNNING IN STATE InferiorRunOk.

Media Status: QMediaPlayer::BufferedMedia

QWidget::paintEngine: Should no longer be called
QWidget::paintEngine: Should no longer be called

In the MP4 that doesn't play:
Thread 21 created.

~"[New Thread 0x8dbff390 (LWP 17705)]\n"
[New Thread 0x8dbff390 (LWP 17705)]
*running,thread-id="21"
dNOTE: INFERIOR STILL RUNNING IN STATE InferiorRunOk.

Media Status: QMediaPlayer::BufferedMedia

QWidget::paintEngine: Should no longer be called
QWidget::paintEngine: Should no longer be called

If you want to see the full debug section from when I hit the button to here I can paste it, but it is VERY long.

JKSH

@MichRX7 said in Showing a mp4 in my app:

Well, there is a lot of output, not sure if you want to see all of it.

...

 Thread 18 created.
>~"[New Thread 0x8d0fc390 (LWP 17529)]\n"
 [New Thread 0x8d0fc390 (LWP 17529)]
>*running,thread-id="18"
dNOTE: INFERIOR STILL RUNNING IN STATE InferiorRunOk.

Looks like you ran it in the Debugger.

Run it normally (click "Run" instead of "Start Debugging" and you should see a lot less output.

MichRX7

Ok, here is the MP4 when I just run:
01:16:58: Starting /tmp/VisualGDB/c/projects/LinuxProject1/Debug/LinuxProject1...
qt5ct: using qt5ct plugin
qt5ct: D-Bus global menu: no
Media Status: QMediaPlayer::LoadingMedia
State: QMediaPlayer::PlayingState
mediaStatus: QMediaPlayer::LoadingMedia error: QMediaPlayer::NoError
Media Status: QMediaPlayer::BufferedMedia
01:17:08: /tmp/VisualGDB/c/projects/LinuxProject1/Debug/LinuxProject1 exited with code 0

MOV file that plays as I expect:
01:18:52: Starting /tmp/VisualGDB/c/projects/LinuxProject1/Debug/LinuxProject1...
qt5ct: using qt5ct plugin
qt5ct: D-Bus global menu: no
Media Status: QMediaPlayer::LoadingMedia
State: QMediaPlayer::PlayingState
mediaStatus: QMediaPlayer::LoadingMedia error: QMediaPlayer::NoError
Media Status: QMediaPlayer::BufferedMedia
01:19:07: /tmp/VisualGDB/c/projects/LinuxProject1/Debug/LinuxProject1 exited with code 0

MOV file that doesn't play (just get black window like MP4 file)
01:20:36: Starting /tmp/VisualGDB/c/projects/LinuxProject1/Debug/LinuxProject1...
qt5ct: using qt5ct plugin
qt5ct: D-Bus global menu: no
Media Status: QMediaPlayer::LoadingMedia
State: QMediaPlayer::PlayingState
mediaStatus: QMediaPlayer::LoadingMedia error: QMediaPlayer::NoError
Media Status: QMediaPlayer::BufferedMedia
QWidget::paintEngine: Should no longer be called
QWidget::paintEngine: Should no longer be called
QWidget::paintEngine: Should no longer be called
QWidget::paintEngine: Should no longer be called
01:20:49: /tmp/VisualGDB/c/projects/LinuxProject1/Debug/LinuxProject1 exited with code 0

MichRX7

Go figure, if I take the MOV that won't play into my video editor and export it as a WMV it plays.
Same goes with the MP4, convert it to WMV and it plays.

Maybe there is an issue with my video software and MP4/MOV? Just odd that I can play them from the command line, but not from within my QT app.

JKSH

@MichRX7 said in Showing a mp4 in my app:

Go figure, if I take the MOV that won't play into my video editor and export it as a WMV it plays.
Same goes with the MP4, convert it to WMV and it plays.

Maybe there is an issue with my video software and MP4/MOV? Just odd that I can play them from the command line, but not from within my QT app.

Sounds like the video codecs aren't being loaded/used correctly in your Qt app.

What version of Qt are you using? What version of OS?

qt5ct: using qt5ct plugin

How did you install Qt?

mediaStatus: QMediaPlayer::LoadingMedia error: QMediaPlayer::NoError

Hmm... nothing in the log jumps out to me, unfortunately.

QWidget::paintEngine: Should no longer be called

This looks somewhat ominous; I'm not sure if this is a clue or not. https://stackoverflow.com/questions/45537627/qwidgetpaintengine-should-no-longer-be-called-appears-when-using-qmediaplay

MichRX7

@JKSH

I am on a Rpi4 running Raspbian GNU/Linux 10 (buster).
I am running Qt Creator 4.8.2 Based on Qt 5.11.3 (GCC 8.3.0, 32 bit)

I tried to install 5.14.1, but failed gloriously (lol). I will give it a try again some day, but wanted to try writing actual code. I believe the 5.11.3 came with Raspbian buster.

JKSH

@MichRX7 said in Showing a mp4 in my app:

I tried to install 5.14.1, but failed gloriously (lol). I will give it a try again some day, but wanted to try writing actual code. I believe the 5.11.3 came with Raspbian buster.

When you're ready to try again, see https://www.tal.org/tutorials/building-qt-512-raspberry-pi as a good place to start.

For now, have a look at the list of multimedia dependencies in the link above. I wonder if the Raspbian's copy of the Qt5Multimedia library was built with all of those in place?

MichRX7

@JKSH

Yes, thank you for all your help and thank you for the insight from everyone on this thread. Right now just trying to do a proof of concept to show some people, and if I can get it to reliably show the wmv files that'll be fine for now.

I actually did try that page, and replaced 5.12.7 with 5.14.1. And it was my plan to try and figure out (using that page) what I did wrong when I'm ready to try again.

JKSH

@MichRX7 said in Showing a mp4 in my app:

I actually did try that page, and replaced 5.12.7 with 5.14.1. And it was my plan to try and figure out (using that page) what I did wrong when I'm ready to try again.

I haven't developed for Raspbian before, but there a chance that the instructions for Qt 5.12.7 might not work with Qt 5.14.1 unmodified -- Some dependency might have changed between versions.

The instructions have been reported to work with Qt 5.12.7 on Raspbian Buster, so that combo will give you the best chance for success.

After you get it working with Qt 5.12.7, then try Qt 5.14.x (or even Qt 5.15: https://www.qt.io/blog/qt-5.15-alpha-released )

Yes, thank you for all your help and thank you for the insight from everyone on this thread. Right now just trying to do a proof of concept to show some people, and if I can get it to reliably show the wmv files that'll be fine for now.

You're welcome. All the best with your project!