Error in opening DB using QSqlQuery

ambershark

@mzimmers Oops missed that output in the original post. Looks set up properly to me.

So some more questions/ideas:

I've never used unixODBC, is there a server or something that needs to run or is it just a library you link? If it is linked do you have it linking properly in your build?
Does the odbc stuff require a plugin? Do you have that plugin loaded in your project?
Is mysql running? Can you access the database outside of your application properly?

The error is a bit confusing as it's saying multiple things. DSN not found. Also there is no default driver. And finally unable to connect. So it could mean it can't connect to the database and the rest is fine, or that it can't find the odbc driver, or that your DSN isn't set up properly.

I'm kind of just throwing out ideas as I've never tried the unixODBC libraries. If you don't get a satisfactory answer and I get some spare time I could install it and get a quick tutorial or list of steps for you to make it work. That's a decent amount of work so we'll save that as a last resort. ;)

Oh and you can set QT_DEBUG_PLUGINS=1 before you run your application and see if the QODBC driver is not being loaded for some reason (and what that reason might be). To do this you would QT_DEBUG_PLUGINS=1 ./myapp or set it for the life of that shell with export QT_DEBUG_PLUGINS=1 then run your app as normal ./myapp.

mzimmers

@ambershark I think you're onto something with your first question. I took a closer look, and discovered that unixODBC is merely an API. Using it requires a driver. I chose MySQL Connector/ODBC, and followed the instructions listed here:

installation

and here:

configuration

But I'm still getting the same error. It's not clear to me how the program in Qt picks up these libraries. There's no mention of them in the .pro file, but I assume it's finding them, or I'd be getting some kind of linker error.

I'm also not sure that the Qt program is getting my environment variables ODBCSYSINI and ODBCINI.

Thanks for any other suggestions.

hskoglund

@mzimmers Actually it's not Qt that picks up the MySQL .so dll, that's what unixODBC suppose to do for you (i.e. a 3-step process: Qt's odbc plugin -> unixODBC -> /usr/local/lib/libmyodbc3.so)

Perhaps unixODBC does not load the libmyodbc.3.so file correctly, does your odbc.ini specify /usr/local... or something else?

mzimmers

@hskoglund: thank you for the clarification. But where did you get the filename libmyodbc.3.so you mention above? I have no such file on my system.

I only have two ODBC configuration files on my entire system with anything in them:

root@debian:/etc# pwd
/etc
root@debian:/etc# ls odbc*
odbc.ini  odbcinst.ini
root@debian:/etc# more odbc*
::::::::::::::
odbc.ini
::::::::::::::
[MySQL-test]
Description     = MySQL test database
Trace       = Off
TraceFile   = stderr
Driver      = MySQL
SERVER      = 127.0.0.1
USER        = root 
PASSWORD    =
PORT        = 3306
DATABASE    = test
::::::::::::::
odbcinst.ini
::::::::::::::
;
;  odbc.ini configuration for Connector/ODBC and Connector/ODBC drivers
;

[ODBC Data Sources]
myodbc3     = MyODBC Driver DSN

[MySQL-test]
Driver       = /usr/local/lib/libmyodbc5a.so
Description  = Connector/ODBC  Driver DSN
SERVER       = localhost
PORT         =
USER         = root
Password     =
Database     = test
OPTION       = 3
SOCKET       =
root@debian:/etc#

hskoglund

I got the name from your link above configuration in it is an odbc.ini example file, and I know from my struggles with MSSQLServer that that Driver= <path to dll/.so file> line is needed, so that unixODBC can load the dll properly.

mzimmers

@hskoglund said in Error in opening DB using QSqlQuery:

I got the name from your link above configuration in it is an odbc.ini example file, and I know from my struggles with MSSQLServer that that Driver= <path to dll/.so file> line is needed, so that unixODBC can load the dll properly.

Interesting. I thought the documentation was just out of date, and that the "3" represented a version that is now 5. (The "a" refers to ANSI vs. Unicode.) Not so?

hskoglund

@mzimmers Yes you're right, it's libmyodbc5a.so now, so unixODBC should load it.
Next pain point is the [DSN] stuff, do you set QSQLDatabase's .setDatabaseName to "MySQL-test"?

mzimmers

@hskoglund : yes I do:

int main(int argc, char *argv[])
{
    QCoreApplication a(argc, argv);
    QSqlDatabase db = QSqlDatabase::addDatabase("QODBC");
    db.setHostName("localhost");
    db.setDatabaseName("MySQL-test");
    bool ok = db.open();

And this open() produces the error that I mention above.

hskoglund

Hmm, just guessing, but have you tried moving your odbc.ini to your home directory?

hskoglund

Another guess: try changing the first part of your odbc.ini to:

[ODBC Data Sources]
MySQL-test  = MyODBC Driver DSN

mzimmers

Just did...same results. I also renamed it to ".odbc.ini" with the same results.

The tutorial author doesn't mention it, but the configuration instructions mention some variables:

export ODBCINI=/usr/local/etc/odbc.ini
export ODBCSYSINI=/usr/local/etc

I've done this, except they point to /etc. But I'm wondering whether this is correct.

Regarding your latest suggestion, should that change be in odbc.ini or odbcinst.ini?

hskoglund

Hi, about [ODBC Data Sources] try putting those 2 lines in both files.

I've googled a bit, and https://lists.mysql.com/myodbc/6311 says that the default location for odbc.ini and odbcinst.ini is /usr/local/etc, so try putting the files there (maybe unixODBC does not see your exports).

mzimmers

@hskoglund : did the insertion of those two lines, and copied the files to /usr/local/etc. Same results.

Configuring this isn't exactly easy, is it?

hskoglund

Believe me, it's even trickier on the Mac, I had some grand plans to make my db library support Windows, Linux and Mac (that's what Qt is all about after all). But to get ODBC work on Linux took maybe 2 or 3 nights, but on the Mac; easily one week :-(

Anyway, perhaps it's time to try another .so file, that post above mentions libodbcmyS.so...

mzimmers

What file are you referencing above?

hskoglund

Hi more google tips
it mentions running odbcinst, e.g. "odbcinst -i -d -f /home/username/odbc/mysql"
I don't remember having to do that for SQLServer but perhaps MySQL requires it

hskoglund

@mzimmers About libodbcmyS.so that I mentioned above, it seems for MySQL there are actually 2 kinds of .so files: one driver flavored and one setup flavored, and that libodbcmyS.so is the latter.
Also, it seems both flavors are needed to be listed in odbcinst.ini.
Sorry for the confusion. Actually that last link seems pretty helpful, not that old (only 10 years!). Also it mentions running isql to test the connection (I remember the isql program as being very helpful for my debugging.)

mzimmers

OK, well I still don't have a libodbcmyS.so. I do have a libmyodbc5S.so; could this be it? And, if so, how am I supposed to list both in the obdcinst.ini file?

Am I using the isql command correctly here?

root@debian:/etc# isql MySQL-test
[ISQL]ERROR: Could not SQLConnect

hskoglund

Yeah, the isql command seems right and the error message seems familiar too :-) (And the error is outside the realm of Qt)

About Qt and MySql: you do know there is a probably simpler way to connect to your MySQL db: not going through the ODBC API, but instead loading Qt's plugin for MySQL directly, by using ::addDatabase("QMYSQL")?

mzimmers

@hskoglund yeah, I've already gotten the QMYSQL plugin working. I'm working with the ODBC stuff for the sake of my education, in case my next job lands me in a Windows environment.

It's strange how all the web pages on ODBC are so old...it is considered obsolescent technology now?

Anyway, I think I'm done for the night. I'll tackle this again tomorrow. Thanks for all your help.