Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Tags
  • Popular
  • Users
  • Groups
  • Search
  • Get Qt Extensions
  • Unsolved
Collapse
Brand Logo
  1. Home
  2. Qt Development
  3. General and Desktop
  4. ITK and VTK headers not found by QT in Windows 8
Qt 6.11 is out! See what's new in the release blog

ITK and VTK headers not found by QT in Windows 8

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved General and Desktop
14 Posts 3 Posters 5.2k Views 1 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • V Offline
    V Offline
    venkatesh
    wrote on last edited by
    #3

    The actual error is Qt is not able to find the header file of ITK. I have included the path in which i have build the ITK using VS 2012. In windows when i build ITK it doesn't generate any header file (.h file) as build in Linux. When i work with the same .pro file in Mac it works fine. I don't know why it doesn't work with Windows

    1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • V Offline
      V Offline
      venkatesh
      wrote on last edited by
      #4

      The problem is I couldn't find a clear way to integrate the ITK and VTK into QT in Windows, as Qt asks for included headers which I could find no where in Windows after building ITK and VTK for QT. When I copied the headers from Mac and set the path to the headers. The QT again produces an error

      @

      cannot find included file "pthread.h"
      @

      which I guess is valid for only Linux...

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • C Offline
        C Offline
        ChrisW67
        wrote on last edited by
        #5

        Qt does not produce the error: that is your C++ compiler.

        Header files are not "generated" they are part of the source code you used to build ITK and/or VTK on Windows. There are plenty of them visible in the "git":http://itk.org/gitweb?p=ITK.git;a=tree;f=Modules/Core/Common/include;h=1ce1109066957a199153c01d411bbdd6d64cea49;hb=HEAD "repository":http://itk.org/gitweb?p=ITK.git;a=tree;f=Modules/Bridge/VTK/include;h=29a036dec94ae9bc3a71fcdc2c8f71b3822d039f;hb=HEAD. Where the the ITK CMake setup installs them during the build would appear to be* in the include folder of the build directory.

        • I am not going to tool up and build this just to find out for you.
        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • V Offline
          V Offline
          venkatesh
          wrote on last edited by
          #6

          Hi...
          Thanks for the message but i could find it only in the source directory in the build directory all the headers are not available. Is there any way to link the headers with Qt?.. I read in forums its just enough if we set the path to the installed ITK and VTK directory. But this is not working out for me.

          1 Reply Last reply
          0
          • C Offline
            C Offline
            ChrisW67
            wrote on last edited by
            #7

            You fix your problems by fixing the INCLUDEPATH variable and then using a suitable relative path in your #include directives.

            1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • V Offline
              V Offline
              venkatesh
              wrote on last edited by
              #8

              Hi I have tried what you said. I have attached a detailed expression of my problem again

              Hi,
              I am creating a project for Image Registration. I had to use windows 8 for executing it. I checked my code with Mac OSX it works perfectly but i have a problem in finding the headers i have used (ITK AND VTK) in Windows it was clearly available in usr/local/include in Mac. But after building the Qt and VTK AND ITK all in VS 2012 Professional 64 bit. I still couldnt find a way to include the headers in Qt Pro

              My pro file looks like this

              @ **#-------------------------------------------------
              #
              # Project created by QtCreator 2013-09-18T14:03:47
              #
              #-------------------------------------------------
              
              QT       += core gui
              
              greaterThan(QT_MAJOR_VERSION, 4): QT += widgets
              
              TARGET = ImageRegistration
              TEMPLATE = app
              
              LIBS += -L/C:/Toolkits/itk-4.4.2/bin/lib/Release/\
              -lITKVtkGlue-4.4\
              -lITKBiasCorrection-4.4\
              -lITKBioCell-4.4\
              -lITKCommon-4.4\
              -lITKDICOMParser-4.4\
              -litkdouble-conversion-4.4\
              -lITKEXPAT-4.4\
              -lITKFEM-4.4\
              -litkgdcmCommon-4.4\
              -litkgdcmDICT-4.4\
              -litkgdcmDSED-4.4\
              -litkgdcmIOD-4.4\
              -litkgdcmjpeg8-4.4\
              -litkgdcmjpeg12-4.4\
              -litkgdcmjpeg16-4.4\
              -litkgdcmMSFF-4.4\
              -litkgdcmuuid-4.4\
              -lITKgiftiio-4.4\
              -litkhdf5_cpp-4.4\
              -litkhdf5-4.4\
              -lITKIOBioRad-4.4\
              -lITKIOBMP-4.4\
              -lITKIOCSV-4.4\
              -lITKIOGDCM-4.4\
              -lITKIOGE-4.4\
              -lITKIOGIPL-4.4\
              -lITKIOHDF5-4.4\
              -lITKIOImageBase-4.4\
              -lITKIOIPL-4.4\
              -lITKIOJPEG-4.4\
              -lITKIOLSM-4.4\
              -lITKIOMesh-4.4\
              -lITKIOMeta-4.4\
              -lITKIONIFTI-4.4\
              -lITKIONRRD-4.4\
              -lITKIOPNG-4.4\
              -lITKIOSiemens-4.4\
              -lITKIOSpatialObjects-4.4\
              -lITKIOStimulate-4.4\
              -lITKIOTIFF-4.4\
              -lITKIOTransformBase-4.4\
              -lITKIOTransformHDF5-4.4\
              -lITKIOTransformInsightLegacy-4.4\
              -lITKIOTransformMatlab-4.4\
              -lITKIOVTK-4.4\
              -lITKIOXML-4.4\
              -litkjpeg-4.4\
              -lITKKLMRegionGrowing-4.4\
              -lITKLabelMap-4.4\
              -lITKMesh-4.4\
              -lITKMetaIO-4.4\
              -litkNetlibSlatec-4.4\
              -lITKniftiio-4.4\
              -lITKNrrdIO-4.4\
              -litkopenjpeg-4.4\
              -lITKOptimizers-4.4\
              -lITKOptimizersv4-4.4\
              -lITKPath-4.4\
              -litkpng-4.4\
              -lITKPolynomials-4.4\
              -lITKQuadEdgeMesh-4.4\
              -lITKReview-4.4\
              -lITKSpatialObjects-4.4\
              -lITKStatistics-4.4\
              -litksys-4.4\
              -litktiff-4.4\
              -litkv3p_lsqr-4.4\
              -litkv3p_netlib-4.4\
              -litkvcl-4.4\
              -lITKVideoCore-4.4\
              -lITKVideoIO-4.4\
              -litkvnl_algo-4.4\
              -litkvnl-4.4\
              -lITKVNLInstantiation-4.4\
              -lITKVTK-4.4\
              -lITKWatersheds-4.4\
              -litkzlib-4.4\
              -lITKznz-4.4
              
              INCLUDEPATH+= C:/Toolkits/itk-4.4.2
              DEPENDPATH+= C:/Toolkits/itk-4.4.2
              
              LIBS += -L/C:/Users/Venky/Desktop/Image_Registration_Files/ImageRegistration/macos/ \
              -lboost_filesystem\
              -lboost_system\
              -lhdf5\
              -lhdf5_cpp\
              -lscilscore\
              -lscilsdomainmodel\
              -lscilsgenericio\
              -lscilshdf5io\
              -llibz
              
              INCLUDEPATH+=C:/Users/Venky/Desktop/Image_Registration_Files/ImageRegistration/boost
              DEPENDPATH+=C:/Users/Venky/Desktop/Image_Registration_Files/ImageRegistration/boost
              
              INCLUDEPATH+=C:/Users/Venky/Desktop/Image_Registration_Files/ImageRegistration/scils
              DEPENDPATH+=C:/Users/Venky/Desktop/Image_Registration_Files/ImageRegistration/scils
              
              INCLUDEPATH+=C:/Users/Venky/Desktop/Image_Registration_Files/ImageRegistration/hdf5
              DEPENDPATH+=C:/Users/Venky/Desktop/Image_Registration_Files/ImageRegistration/hdf5
              
              INCLUDEPATH+=C:/Users/Venky/Desktop/Image_Registration_Files/ImageRegistration/hdf5-static
              DEPENDPATH+=C:/Users/Venky/Desktop/Image_Registration_Files/ImageRegistration/hdf5-static
              
              
              LIBS += -L/C:/Toolkits/vtk-5.10/bin/bin/Release/\
              -lQVTK\
              -lvtkalglib\
              -lvtkCharts\
              -lvtkCommon\
              -lvtkDICOMParser\
              -lvtkexoIIc\
              -lvtkexpat\
              -lvtkFiltering\
              -lvtkfreetype\
              -lvtkftgl\
              -lvtkGenericFiltering\
              -lvtkGeovis\
              -lvtkGraphics\
              -lvtkhdf5_hl\
              -lvtkhdf5\
              -lvtkHybrid\
              -lvtkImaging\
              -lvtkInfovis\
              -lvtkIO\
              -lvtkjpeg\
              -lvtklibxml2\
              -lvtkmetaio\
              -lvtkNetCDF_cxx\
              -lvtkNetCDF\
              -lvtkpng\
              -lvtkproj4\
              -lvtkRendering\
              -lvtksqlite\
              -lvtksys\
              -lvtktiff\
              -lvtkverdict\
              -lvtkViews\
              -lvtkVolumeRendering\
              -lvtkWidgets\
              -lvtkzlib
              
              INCLUDEPATH+= C:/Toolkits/vtk-5.10
              DEPENDPATH+= C:/Toolkits/vtk-5.10
              
              INCLUDEPATH+=$$PWD
              
              SOURCES += main.cpp\
                      ImageRegistrationImplementation.cpp\
              listWidget.cpp\
              overlayview.cpp \
              transforms.cpp \
              model.cpp \
              imageviewer.cpp
              
              
              HEADERS  += ImageRegistrationImplementation.h\
              listWidget.h\
                  overlayview.h \
                  transforms.h \
                  model.h \
                  imageviewer.h
              
              
              FORMS    += ImageRegistration.ui
              ** @
              

              I have included the installation directory of the ITK and VTK. I couldnt include the path where the headers are as i couldnt find everyone of them. I even tried copying the headers from my Mac to the the installed itk and vtk directory without any success. It would be great if anyone exactly tell me how to link the headers in Qt Creator.

              1 Reply Last reply
              0
              • T Offline
                T Offline
                tilsitt
                wrote on last edited by
                #9

                Hi,

                You built ITK and VTK with visual: there should be a project named INSTALL in your solution. Did you generate it (it is not always generated when you generate the whole solution)? What is the content of the following directories:

                -C:/Toolkits/itk-4.4.2
                -C:/Toolkits/vtk-5.10

                1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • V Offline
                  V Offline
                  venkatesh
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #10

                  Hi i generated using all build in some forums everyone suggested to do so. But the problem is finding the location of the headers are really causing problem.As i wrote my code in Mac. I have to use it for executing in windows.

                  ITK
                  @
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\bin"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\CMakeFiles"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\CMakeTmp"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\config"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\Debug"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\Examples"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ExternalData"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\lib"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\Modules"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\Testing"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\Utilities"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\x64"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ALL_BUILD.vcxproj"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ALL_BUILD.vcxproj.filters"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\cmake_install.cmake"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\CMakeCache.txt"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\CPackConfig.cmake"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\CPackSourceConfig.cmake"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\CTestCustom.cmake"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\DartConfiguration.tcl"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\INSTALL.vcxproj"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\INSTALL.vcxproj.filters"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ITK.sdf"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ITK.sln"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ITKConfig.cmake"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ITKConfigVersion.cmake"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ITKData.vcxproj"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ITKData.vcxproj.filters"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ITKData_config.cmake"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ITKHeaderTests.vcxproj"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ITKHeaderTests.vcxproj.filters"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ITKTargets.cmake"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\PACKAGE.vcxproj"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\PACKAGE.vcxproj.filters"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\single-doxygen.config"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ZERO_CHECK.vcxproj"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin\ZERO_CHECK.vcxproj.filters"
                  @

                  in src

                  @
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src.ExternalData"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\CMake"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\Documentation"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\Examples"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\Modules"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\Testing"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\Utilities"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\Wrapping"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\CMakeLists.txt"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\CTestConfig.cmake"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\GettingStarted.txt"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\LICENSE"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\NOTICE"
                  "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src\README.txt"

                  @

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • V Offline
                    V Offline
                    venkatesh
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #11

                    In VTK

                    SRC

                    @

                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Charts"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Chemistry"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\CMake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Common"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Examples"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Filtering"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\GenericFiltering"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Geovis"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Graphics"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\GUISupport"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Hybrid"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Imaging"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Infovis"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\IO"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Parallel"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Rendering"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\TextAnalysis"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Utilities"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Views"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\VolumeRendering"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Widgets"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Wrapping"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\CMakeLists.txt"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Copyright.txt"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\CTestConfig.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\README.html"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\Testing.txt"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\UseVTK.cmake.in"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\vtkBanner.gif"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\VTKConfig.cmake.in"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\vtkConfigure.h.in"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\VTKConfigVersion.cmake.in"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\VTKCPack.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\vtkGenerateVTKConfig.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\vtkIncludeDirectories.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\vtkLogo.ico"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\vtkLogo.jpg"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\vtkMacros.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\src\vtkToolkits.h.in"

                    @
                    BIN

                    @

                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\bin"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Charts"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\CMake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\CMakeFiles"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\CMakeTmp"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Common"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Debug"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Filtering"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\GenericFiltering"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Geovis"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Graphics"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\GUISupport"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Hybrid"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Imaging"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Infovis"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\IO"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Release"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Rendering"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Testing"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Utilities"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Views"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\VolumeRendering"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkstd"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Widgets"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Win32"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\Wrapping"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\ALL_BUILD.vcxproj"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\ALL_BUILD.vcxproj.filters"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\cmake_install.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\CMakeCache.txt"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\CTestCustom.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\DartConfiguration.tcl"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\INSTALL.vcxproj"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\INSTALL.vcxproj.filters"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\proj_config.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\UseVTK.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\VTK.sdf"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\VTK.sln"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\VTKBuildSettings.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkChartsInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkCommonInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\VTKCompileToolsConfig.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\VTKConfig.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\VTKConfigQt.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkConfigure.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\VTKConfigVersion.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkFilteringInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkGenericFilteringInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkGeovisInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkGraphicsInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkHybridInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkImagingInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkInfovisInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkIOInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkRenderingInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\VTKTargets.cmake"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkToolkits.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkViewsInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkVolumeRenderingInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\vtkWidgetsInstantiator.h"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\ZERO_CHECK.vcxproj"
                    "C:\Toolkits\vtk-5.10\bin\ZERO_CHECK.vcxproj.filters"

                    @

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • T Offline
                      T Offline
                      tilsitt
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #12

                      Ok, your directory "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin" looks like a shadow build directory. When using cmake to generate the visual studio solution, what directory did you specify for the installation?

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • V Offline
                        V Offline
                        venkatesh
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #13

                        This is the same directory i specified.During my build. Is there any problem about my bin directory??...

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • T Offline
                          T Offline
                          tilsitt
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #14

                          Open the cmake wizard. Fill the line "Where is your source code" with ""C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\src". Fill the line "Where to build the binaries" with "C:\Toolkits\itk-4.4.2\bin". Check the "Advanced" option in the next line at the right. In the cmake variables, you should have "CMAKE_INSTALL_PREFIX": what is the value?

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          0

                          • Login

                          • Login or register to search.
                          • First post
                            Last post
                          0
                          • Categories
                          • Recent
                          • Tags
                          • Popular
                          • Users
                          • Groups
                          • Search
                          • Get Qt Extensions
                          • Unsolved