[Suggestion] Wiki page bread crumb can show category

? Offline

The breadcrumb in any wiki page (say Qt Quick Best Practices) currently just shows, Wiki Home >> Qt Quick Best Practices

Do you think its a good idea to show the category too, so the bread crumb would appear as

Wiki Home >> Qt Quick >> Qt Quick Best Practices

This will help in navigation too

alexander

chetankjain, yes, it simplifies navigation.

mgran

Good stuff, adding it to the to-do list.

We will have to figure out what to do with multiple categories per wiki page, but we could just take the first one for the breadcrumb I guess.

? Offline

would it be feasible to track how the user got to that page and then show the corresponding crumb ... if that is too much of a pain, then first category should be ok

leinir

That is a different style of breadcrumbs trail, a navigation trail (the original breadcrumbs, as in from the fairytale ;) ). Those are really quite nifty as well, though, and the data can be used for other interesting data gathering, such as who went to some page from what other pages more often. Everything2.com* operates in this manner, and it is... somewhat addictive :)

*E2 can be compared to the Hitchiker's Guide to the Galaxy the same way you might compare Wikipedia to the Encyclopedia Galactica... to use a suitably geeky comparison ;)

mgran

[quote author="leinir" date="1291207443"]*E2 can be compared to the Hitchiker's Guide to the Galaxy the same way you might compare Wikipedia to the Encyclopedia Galactica... to use a suitably geeky comparison ;)[/quote]

I had to think about that for a while, but I got it now :D

DenisKormalev

mariusg, about multiple categories and breadcrumbs. I think that good solution will be to show in breadcrumb all categories in some drop-down list.

? Offline

[quote author="Denis Kormalev" date="1291224942"]mariusg, about multiple categories and breadcrumbs. I think that good solution will be to show in breadcrumb all categories in some drop-down list.[/quote]

that would be good, but not sure how easy to maintain, when you consider nested categories .. might end up over complicating the feature

DenisKormalev

chetankjain, yeah, maybe. Marius, Gurudutt, what are you think about it?

goetz

I'd only display the first category (that could be considered the main category). Don't know if anyone ever clicks on a category drop down box in a bread crumb ;-)

mgran

Most pages will have only one category, so to keep it simple I suggest we use the first occurrence of a category and use that.

Probably better ways to do it, but it's an edge case so lets make it as simple as possible, but no simpler (freely after Albert Einstein)

DenisKormalev

Marius, reasonable enough.

? Offline

vote +1 @ marius

mgran

Update: We have this working on the dev server, it will be in the next roll-out.

vsorokin

mariusg, Good news! When will be next roll-out? ;)

mgran

Our release manager, gurudutt here on devnet, is down with a cold this week (it's freezing here!), so we are a bit behind on our 14-day release cycle. But as soon as we are all hands on deck again, we will get it out. Possibly next week.

giesbert

So, we wish all the best and that gurudutt gets well again... :-)

CreMindES

Good news to hear :) I wish gurudutt a speedy recovery! I'm happy to see, that people like chetankjain always has some good idea, that you guys can make real.

Back to the topic, first category is totally okay.

mgran

Have a look, this feature went live today :)

gurudutt

Thank you all for your good wishes in this thread :)