Have you met a load problem of XmlListModel in an embedded platform

[cokefish]

I met a problem of this.

I use Qt 4.7.4 for both desktop and Qtembedded platform development,
When I use a XmlListModel to load some xml file in local directory,
then the difference occurred.

• On desktop, the xml file load instantly and correctly as what the file is.
• On Qtembedded platform, the XmlListModel seems never loaded,
  It kept loading without stop and the status property of XmlListModel object was held to be a constant 2, regardless of I was using relative path or absolute path of the xml file

I looked for Qt assistant
it is said that in QML XmlListModel Element
#----------------
read-only status : enumeration
Specifies the model loading status, which can be one of the following:

XmlListModel.Null - No XML data has been set for this model.
XmlListModel.Ready - The XML data has been loaded into the model.
XmlListModel.Loading - The model is in the process of reading and loading XML data.
XmlListModel.Error - An error occurred while the model was loading. See errorString() for details about the error.
#----------------

For that the xml file has never been load successfully, that I think the constant "2" must be the third value *XmlListModel.Loading *.
I should rather ask why this happened.
Is there some difference between the qmlapplicationviewer betwenn the desktop and the Qtembedded platform?

Thank you.

[cokefish]

What in my understanding the xml file should be automatically loaded when the qml file using the XmlListModel executed.

If my understanding is correct?

[deimos]

bq. If my understanding is correct?

yes, thats correct. Maybe you have malformed the XmlListModel parameters. Can you provide that code for testing ?

[cokefish]

I put my xml and qml file both in qml/myapp/myfunc folder

and then content of the source code are

• qml/myapp/myfunc/xmldata.xml
  @<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
  <List>
  <Line type="Kind" index="0">
  <title>Kind 1</title>
  </Line>
  <Line type="Item" index="1">
  <title>Item one</title>
  <id>id0001</id>
  <comment>Item one comment</comment>
  <times>1</times>
  <rank>red</rank>
  </Line>
  <Line type="Item" index="2">
  <title>Item two</title>
  <id>id0002</id>
  <comment>Item two comment</comment>
  <times>1</times>
  <rank>red</rank>
  </Line>
  <Line type="Item" index="3">
  <title>Item three</title>
  <id>id0003</id>
  <comment>Item three comment</comment>
  <times>2</times>
  <rank>gray</rank>
  </Line>
  </List>@

• qml/myapp/myfunc/xmldata.qml
  @// import QtQuick 1.0 // to target S60 5th Edition or Maemo 5
  import QtQuick 1.1

Rectangle {
id: root
width: 480
height: 800

XmlListModel {
    id: xmlModel
    source: "xmldata.xml"      
    query: "/List/Line"

    XmlRole { name: "type";     query: "@type/string()" }
    XmlRole { name: "index";     query: "@index/string()" }

    XmlRole { name: "title";    query: "title/string()" }

    XmlRole { name: "id";       query: "id/string()" }
    XmlRole { name: "comment";  query: "comment/string()" }
    XmlRole { name: "times";    query: "times/string()" }
    XmlRole { name: "rank";     query: "rank/string()" }
}

...
function do_xmldata_work()
{
console.log("do_xmldata_work begin>: ")
while(xmlModel.status != XmlListModel.Ready)
console.log("loading xml file: " + xmlModel.status)
console.log("loading xml file: " + xmlModel.status + " || finished")

    ...
}

}
@

[cokefish]

I want to call the do_xmldata_work() function from some other qml file.
When I do this:

• On desktop
  it will output as follows:

bq. do_xmldata_work begin>:
loading xml file: 1 || finished

• on Qtembedded platform
  it will output:

bq. do_xmldata_work begin>:
loading xml file: 2
loading xml file: 2
loading xml file: 2
loading xml file: 2
loading xml file: 2
loading xml file: 2
loading xml file: 2
...

[deimos]

I can't tell whats going wrong :( . The xml file seems to be found by XmlListModel, but my suspicion goes to the function do_xmldata_work(). Can you add in XmlListModel element this code and comment out the content of that function:
@
if (status === XmlListModel.Ready) console.log("XmlListModel.Ready ", count);
if (status === XmlListModel.Loading) console.log("XmlListModel.Loading");
if (status === XmlListModel.Error) console.log("XmlListModel.Error: ", errorString);
if (status === XmlListModel.Null) console.log("XmlListModel.Null");@

[cokefish]

Do you means that change
@function do_xmldata_work()
{
console.log("do_xmldata_work begin>: ")
while(xmlModel.status != XmlListModel.Ready)
console.log("loading xml file: " + xmlModel.status)
console.log("loading xml file: " + xmlModel.status + " || finished")

    ...
}@

into
@function do_xmldata_work()
{
console.log("do_xmldata_work begin>: ")
//while(xmlModel.status != XmlListModel.Ready)
// console.log("loading xml file: " + xmlModel.status)
if (status === XmlListModel.Ready) console.log("XmlListModel.Ready ", count);
if (status === XmlListModel.Loading) console.log("XmlListModel.Loading");
if (status === XmlListModel.Error) console.log("XmlListModel.Error: ", errorString);
if (status === XmlListModel.Null) console.log("XmlListModel.Null");

    console.log("loading xml file: " + xmlModel.status + " || finished")

    ...
}@

[deimos]

oh sorry. I forgot to write the signal. I mean this:

@XmlListModel {
id: xmlModel
....
onStatusChanged: {
if (status === XmlListModel.Ready) console.log("XmlListModel.Ready ", count);
if (status === XmlListModel.Loading) console.log("XmlListModel.Loading");
if (status === XmlListModel.Error) console.log("XmlListModel.Error: ", errorString);
if (status === XmlListModel.Null) console.log("XmlListModel.Null");
}

}@

and do not call do_xmldata_work() function. Just for testing and see if the xml file has problems

[cokefish]

OK, I will try, it may cost some time on both platforms
Thank you very much.

[cokefish]

Using
@ XmlListModel {
id: xmlModel
....
onStatusChanged: {
if (status === XmlListModel.Ready) console.log("XmlListModel.Ready ", count);
if (status === XmlListModel.Loading) console.log("XmlListModel.Loading");
if (status === XmlListModel.Error) console.log("XmlListModel.Error: ", errorString);
if (status === XmlListModel.Null) console.log("XmlListModel.Null");
}

}@

• On desktop： Only one line output
  @XmlListModel.Loading
  XmlListModel.Ready 4@

• On Qtembedded： Only one line output
  @XmlListModel.Loading@

[cokefish]

It seems that on Qtembedded platform, that the loading never finished.
Why, am I using the the wrong path of the xml file?

[deimos]

bq. Why, am I using the the wrong path of the xml file?

That was my first thought, but if XmlModelList doesn't find the file an Error or Null signal should be emitted. You also can try to store the xml file in a known directory and set the source property with the full path.
What is your embedded platform ?

[cokefish]

I have tried the absolute path before, it will output all the same.
In fact, I do not know what my embedded platform is.
I only know that the toolchain is from freescale,
for that the compiler is called as "arm-fsl-linux-gnueabi-g++" with a "fsl", I guessed that it was a freescale platform.
Maybe iMx53 serials. But I do not know exactly.

If this is a bug, where the bug is locating in your mind.
In the "qmlapplicationviewer" source in my project,
or somewhere underneath in the Qt framework?

[cokefish]

with a wrong path
@source: "errorxmldata.xml"@
on Desktop outputs
@XmlListModel.Loading
XmlListModel.Error: [object Object]@

while on Qtembeded platform
@XmlListModel.Loading
XmlListModel.Error: [object Object]@

The same as you thought.

[deimos]

Sorry but I have no more suggestions.
I searched if there is some on "bugreports":https://bugreports.qt-project.org but didn't found any. You can try there to file a new bug reporting on which platform you find it.

good luck